RE: One Night Werewolf - Round Two - Day i
05-23-2014, 05:07 PM
I'm completely lost now, let me try to work out something.
First off, we're assuming Slorange's mason claim is true. Second, we're assuming Chwoka is werewolf and not minion. According to Gnauga there's only one wolf but a drunk might have picked it up... yeah, I'm confused here.
What's confirmed to me is that I was Insomniac and I woke up a Robber. I can back up Granola's claim.
We have three people claiming Seer. The most logical chain of events is that one is the real Seer, one is a Tanner, and one is werewolf-aligned. Since the last could be a Minion, it's not in our interest to vote any of them.
We have one person claiming Doppelganger. What we can't be sure on is who they copied or what role they had. Their claim is "I copied SeaWyrm who was Seer", and if this is true then Chwoka was a minion. But Chwoka is claiming former wolf.
Let's play a game of "how many people could be lying".
Slorange: Claims to be the only Mason.
Donut: Claims to be Troublemaker who swapped Slorange and Chwoka.
Schazer: Claims to be Seer, hasn't actually said anything else. Could be claiming a check on Donut, but hasn't done so.
SeaWyrm: Claims to be Seer who checked Chwoka and found him to be a minion.
Granola: Claims to be Robber who stole Insomniac from me. (Backed up by me.)
Chwoka: Claims to have been Wolf. Hasn't mentioned a partner.
Gnauga: Claims to have been Seer who checked unused cards and found Wolf and Hunter.
Palamedes: Apparently drunk who says he picked up Hunter based on Gnauga's check... wait a minute!
Pala could be a drunk-turned-wolf claiming to be drunk-turned-hunter. If he's a wolf and we lynch him, we win; if he's hunter, we get a second shot. The only scenario where he's not our best lynch is one where Gnauga is lying.
Vote: Palamedes.
Now I still need to work out if Slorange is the best chance for that second shot. Not entirely convinced yet.
First off, we're assuming Slorange's mason claim is true. Second, we're assuming Chwoka is werewolf and not minion. According to Gnauga there's only one wolf but a drunk might have picked it up... yeah, I'm confused here.
What's confirmed to me is that I was Insomniac and I woke up a Robber. I can back up Granola's claim.
We have three people claiming Seer. The most logical chain of events is that one is the real Seer, one is a Tanner, and one is werewolf-aligned. Since the last could be a Minion, it's not in our interest to vote any of them.
We have one person claiming Doppelganger. What we can't be sure on is who they copied or what role they had. Their claim is "I copied SeaWyrm who was Seer", and if this is true then Chwoka was a minion. But Chwoka is claiming former wolf.
Let's play a game of "how many people could be lying".
Slorange: Claims to be the only Mason.
Donut: Claims to be Troublemaker who swapped Slorange and Chwoka.
Schazer: Claims to be Seer, hasn't actually said anything else. Could be claiming a check on Donut, but hasn't done so.
SeaWyrm: Claims to be Seer who checked Chwoka and found him to be a minion.
Granola: Claims to be Robber who stole Insomniac from me. (Backed up by me.)
Chwoka: Claims to have been Wolf. Hasn't mentioned a partner.
Gnauga: Claims to have been Seer who checked unused cards and found Wolf and Hunter.
Palamedes: Apparently drunk who says he picked up Hunter based on Gnauga's check... wait a minute!
Pala could be a drunk-turned-wolf claiming to be drunk-turned-hunter. If he's a wolf and we lynch him, we win; if he's hunter, we get a second shot. The only scenario where he's not our best lynch is one where Gnauga is lying.
Vote: Palamedes.
Now I still need to work out if Slorange is the best chance for that second shot. Not entirely convinced yet.
There's no reason for this | Or this | Death is inevitable | You can't challenge fate | The smallest change | I'm overwhelmed
I'm serious | It makes perfect sense | Easy as ABC! | I can't even explain it | Cleaning up someone else's mess
I suck | I rule | I've got it made | Really, I'm serious | This bugs me | It's all lies | I want to believe | Beauty is a curse
I'm serious | It makes perfect sense | Easy as ABC! | I can't even explain it | Cleaning up someone else's mess
I suck | I rule | I've got it made | Really, I'm serious | This bugs me | It's all lies | I want to believe | Beauty is a curse