SCP-MAFIA -NIGHT 4 - ...again!? 10/21

Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
SCP-MAFIA -NIGHT 4 - ...again!? 10/21
RE: SCP-MAFIA - DAY 3 - Double Cacti Homicide 14/21
(07-12-2013, 01:18 PM)Palamedes Wrote: »I jumped on you because while it's not a whole lot, I kind of agree with Dini?

On what?

What did he even say, because I missed it. All I recall that was even remotely specific is that he quoted me yesterday and didn't actually explain anything about why the quote bothered him.

I mean, if he's implied reasons and you agree with those implied reasons, at least say what they are? Although the fact that he's only implying reasons instead of stating them still doesn't make him look great from my perspective.

And essentially, your reasoning on piester is looking a lot like "hey, something totally happened in the night that makes piester look anti-town", and that's vague enough that you could make something up if it turns out that whoops, somehow he was town after all. If you don't want to share, then don't share, but you're not getting my support if all you've got is the vaguest of softclaims.

So basically, your response hasn't changed anything. My vote stands.

bigro, I notice you're not actually explaining why I'm suspicious either. If it's just a gut feeling, say that. If it's something else, say that.

In response to Kieros, who's actually given an explanation for his vote, my D2 reasoning on Felix was basically all I had to go on. The reasoning he explicitly stated was incredibly suspicious, and on top of that he was mildly supported by known scum. What more was I supposed to say? And I didn't find anything that happened during the rest of the day particularly swayed me to change my vote, although I was admittedly pretty disengaged.

I could understand going after me for switching from Felix to Red on D1, but nobody is actually saying that. If that's the reason, why is no one actually saying that? If that's not the reason, then what is?


Messages In This Thread
RE: SCP-MAFIA - DAY 3 - Double Cacti Homicide 14/21 - by Dragon Fogel - 07-12-2013, 07:11 PM