RE: SCP-MAFIA - DAY 3 - Double Cacti Homicide 14/21
07-12-2013, 05:34 AM
The votals stand as follows:
Purple Walrus: 2 (piester, bigro)
piester: 3 (Palamedes, myw, Supah Kiven)
Dragon Fogel: 1 (Mirdini)
And since I bothered to bring that up, I guess I may as well take an actual crack at playing.
Mirdini hasn't actually said anything about why he's voting me, Pala was willing to vote based on that anyways. Likewise, Pala hasn't explained why he thinks piester is the cactus killer and is starting a wagon on that basis. Purple Walrus is probably scum; Sruix was basically cheering that lynch on yesterday and I'm betting he knew it wouldn't work. However, that also suggests a lynch on him today might not work either.
Out of those three lynches I'd go for Piester the most, but there's no reason to limit myself. Pala's hopped on a lynch without explaining any reasons for why, and is pushing one on what seems to be mechanical reasons without explaining what those reasons are.
I don't like lynches that aren't actually backed up with reasoning, whether it's people hopping on or starting them.
Vote: Pala
Give me some reasons. If you don't want to get into detail on how you know what you do about piester, then either give us the case against piester without mechanics, or explain why you were willing to vote me.
I'm also giving Mirdini a look. If Purple Walrus is as hard-to-kill as he appears, then pushing that lynch doesn't tell us anything. For that matter, neither does hopping on the bandwagon. Since then, all he's done is vote me and say "explanation forthcoming".
I may take another look at the thread if I feel up to it later; honestly this is mostly based on my impressions of today, which is Super Quiet Day. Although, I do think that if people aren't actually saying much even when they're pushing lynches, that isn't really going to help with activity.
Purple Walrus: 2 (piester, bigro)
piester: 3 (Palamedes, myw, Supah Kiven)
Dragon Fogel: 1 (Mirdini)
And since I bothered to bring that up, I guess I may as well take an actual crack at playing.
Mirdini hasn't actually said anything about why he's voting me, Pala was willing to vote based on that anyways. Likewise, Pala hasn't explained why he thinks piester is the cactus killer and is starting a wagon on that basis. Purple Walrus is probably scum; Sruix was basically cheering that lynch on yesterday and I'm betting he knew it wouldn't work. However, that also suggests a lynch on him today might not work either.
Out of those three lynches I'd go for Piester the most, but there's no reason to limit myself. Pala's hopped on a lynch without explaining any reasons for why, and is pushing one on what seems to be mechanical reasons without explaining what those reasons are.
I don't like lynches that aren't actually backed up with reasoning, whether it's people hopping on or starting them.
Vote: Pala
Give me some reasons. If you don't want to get into detail on how you know what you do about piester, then either give us the case against piester without mechanics, or explain why you were willing to vote me.
I'm also giving Mirdini a look. If Purple Walrus is as hard-to-kill as he appears, then pushing that lynch doesn't tell us anything. For that matter, neither does hopping on the bandwagon. Since then, all he's done is vote me and say "explanation forthcoming".
I may take another look at the thread if I feel up to it later; honestly this is mostly based on my impressions of today, which is Super Quiet Day. Although, I do think that if people aren't actually saying much even when they're pushing lynches, that isn't really going to help with activity.
There's no reason for this | Or this | Death is inevitable | You can't challenge fate | The smallest change | I'm overwhelmed
I'm serious | It makes perfect sense | Easy as ABC! | I can't even explain it | Cleaning up someone else's mess
I suck | I rule | I've got it made | Really, I'm serious | This bugs me | It's all lies | I want to believe | Beauty is a curse
I'm serious | It makes perfect sense | Easy as ABC! | I can't even explain it | Cleaning up someone else's mess
I suck | I rule | I've got it made | Really, I'm serious | This bugs me | It's all lies | I want to believe | Beauty is a curse