Post making contest 1.0

"What do you guys think? Are any of Akumu's rules simple exclusive or simple inclusive? How would you categorize some of the other possible rules?"

"1 and 5 seem to be simple inclusive, and I'm pretty sure this post will pass them."



"At a glance 4 seems to be simple exclusive, as blank posts pass it. However, combining posts that pass it has produced posts that don't; see BUDDY."

"We had a theory on 2 that would be simple inclusive but it isn't working consistently."

"Another rule type is counting rules, which count something in the post and requires that count to meet some condition. Rules which require a count GREATER THAN a number are also simple inclusive; rules which require a count LESS THAN a number are simple exclusive. However, there are rules which have both GREATER THAN and LESS THAN requirements, which do not cleanly fit into either category. Additionally, there can be more complex counting-based rules, such as 'the number of e's in the post must be a prime number', which is not a simple greater than/less than comparison."

"And then, of course, there are meta rules which take into account the fact that this takes place on a forum. We have seen plenty of examples. Or perhaps the forum-specific rules should be considered separately from rules about rules? I'm not sure offhand."