Nostalgfia - GAME OVER SCUM WIN

ac the reason the turnaround was fast is because it's a guilty, that's (almost always) a sure thing and lynching scum is the name of the game. As for why it's happening so late, I deliberately held back a the result as long as felt safe. If I had dropped it earlier in the day the lynch would have progressed more naturally as opposed to jumping off someone sure, but we would have lost a lot of the progress we made today on CSJ and others.

Was thinking that too. Honestly it's a smart move

Do we have a solid game plan to lynch any other people after this? Or do we need one? I know my list goes getting rid of CSJ first, then looking at n-o/robottobt and then who knows what after that

we arent going to put a list of who we're going to lynch thats bad

Well Wheat I am almost completely positive CB is mafia, while I think CSJ is most likely 3rd party and maybe mafia. Living mafia is the most harmful thing, moreso than 3rd party for sure (who can always hurt scum just as much as they do town, even if the odds are slightly less likely). Also, like I already mentioned, Coldblooded is going to be a wasted lynch down the line, and is probably not going to be killable otherwise, while I think CSJ can still get killed without wasting a lynch (same goes for n-o and to a slightly lesser extent Robo) and still give us the same info at this point as if we had lynched them.

A specific ordered list gives scum some idea of who we don't want alive which means it helps them plan mislynches, distractions, and redirects. It's okay to have the couple of obvious ones that we do at the point we're at (so as to avoid scum having a sure chance of messing up any town night plans) but the more detail the more dangerous things get.

*dog wonders, if you (and mirdini) still think CSJ is scum, why would you not want to lynch them for the greater amount of info that brings, considering the possibility of you dying tonight? cb would still be taken as scum while still alive; however we would have sureness of csj's alignment too*

If it's worth anything, CSJ, if they're thirdparty, would have a possibility of targetting a mafiaperson tonight (this is kind of aligned with your argument earlier that a third party would be a threat to both the mafia and the town) - so using this to our advantage we leave them alone tonight and lynch CB who is moreso confirmed a maf, according to Pala

I don't really think the order in which CSJ/CB are lynched matters TOO much, anyway??

we arent going to put a list of who we're going to lynch thats bad

A specific ordered list gives scum some idea of who we don't want alive which means it helps them plan mislynches, distractions, and redirects. It's okay to have the couple of obvious ones that we do at the point we're at (so as to avoid scum having a sure chance of messing up any town night plans) but the more detail the more dangerous things get.

My bad!

*dog wonders, if you (and mirdini) still think CSJ is scum, why would you not want to lynch them for the greater amount of info that brings, considering the possibility of you dying tonight? cb would still be taken as scum while still alive; however we would have sureness of csj's alignment too*

what Pala said, and also after all this

計画通り :)

Ugh. I'm getting confused. Are you lynching me, or pala? Reading into my death before it happens? That's awfully helpful of you, sunspider and I appreciate it.

All that said, CSJ is busy melting down right now

You could argue that, but when and why? How much of what I said today are actual leads and how much is intentional? Are there no leads? Are we in fact, all mafia? Are there third party in the game? (yes)

Have fun with that.

I most certainly wouldn't salt a day's worth of information before a pre-arranged lynch. But then knowing that people would rjink I did, maybe I would lie knowing you would't believe it.

Never trust a mafioso when death is on the line? All this presumptuous speculating is fun. I just want to be around when it all piles up.

2 is a prime number, right?

*laughs numerically*

I'm faaairly sure we can classify CSJ's alignment as "not town", and clarifying whether it's mafia or third party can wait imo

especially because I honestly half-believe Sunspider's suggestion that CSJ is a prime-day jester at this point

Vote: Coldblooded

that's 8 votes on her now yeah, halt ye voting henceforth

in fact since I know for a fact I'll be back around day end unvote to prevent accidental (or 'accidental') hammers

if pala's not town and is Deceiving us I'd guess 3p lyncher before I'd guess scum
but as it stands pala could probably get CB lynched without resorting to this so I don't think that's likely
(maybe wheat's the one with the lyncher wincon here :p)
and like dini said pala has been fairly towny or at least neutral and CB has been scummy so it's...not that hard of a pill to swallow

unvote
CSJ how do you feel about us not lynching you

(man, stuff not being in the database is annoying...then again, we don't have a database in regular games, so maybe I'm just already-spoilt by its existence)

btw @Pala if it's not in the database then how'd you know what it would do?

Current Votes

Wheat: (1) (Nercania)
Nercania: (2) (Wheat, Akumu)
Pharmacy: (2) (Coldblooded, A52)
CSJ: (1) (Robust Laser)
Coldblooded: (7) (Palamedes, Cat, Solaris, Sunspider, Granolaman, AwkwardCarapace, Schazer)

Abstaining: (6) (AgentBlue, Pharmacy, Robbobt, CSJ, Mirdini, Seedy)

With 19 alive it takes 10 to hardlynch and 4 to softlynch.

Countdown to Day End

oh ALSO there could be two teams but gosh I hope not

So like two scum teams or a mafia+third party.

Hopefully tonight's thing would be less...recursive because as much as last night's redirection clusterfuck was amusing, it certainly was too much of a mess to be informative.

Dammit.

I think there needs to be a definitive end to all the mucking around from today, so while I am a little mad at not winning, I strongly recommend hammering Coldblooded.

oh shush if you actually wanted to get lynched you would have saved the villainous laughter for when we already did it 35 minutes ago

oh shush if you actually wanted to get lynched you would have saved the villainous laughter for when we already did it 35 minutes ago

Are you implying that I'm better at this game than my posting in this thread would suggest? Because I think that would be a mistake. :P

*barks at coldblooded to vote today........ in real life!!!! in the ohio primary elections!!!!*

Hi Wheat! I did in fact remember to vote in real IRL life. They even gave me a cool sticker so I could let everyone know that I Ohio-shape voting and I was gonna bring it home and write somebody's name on it next time I wanted to cast a vote here so that people could see that I Ohio voting [enter name here] but then I lost the sticker and now I can't vote anymore. :(

Anyway the gubernatorial candidate that they selected was from my hometown even though I didn't vote for him, and my district nominated the one openly gay candidate for house rep so that's cool I guess.

Oh and CSJ, if you happen to be friends with any passenger pigeons, please tell them to go to the same spot as yesterday and we'll see if we can't work something out.

Okay, I think that's as far as I have time to read tonight, I promise to try and make it to page 15 by tomorrow, hope I didn't miss anything important in the last couple days. ;)

Hey has anyone in this thread watched Kung Fu Panda 3 yet?

I haven't.

Hey has anyone in this thread watched Kung Fu Panda 3 yet?

I haven't.

Sorry wrong thread.

Vote Coldblooded

And with now 9 votes on CB we still have 5 hours to chat! Isn’t that nice.

Granolaman, you mentioned earlier there were some QT questions you’d asked that might be interesting to talk about if answered. Anything come from that?

I have two unanswered dealios with items still unexplained and kinda annoyed, since they relate to last night. Hopefully with the extra help, that gets straightened out.

unvote

big lel

also boy howdy good thing seedy and I unvoted

coldblooded im sorry that you didnt get to go down in a cooler manner and you settled on this

F

Yeah it was a nice shot, I'm sorry I caught you so early. I haven't seen KFP III either but I heard it was pretty decent.

I'm guessing there's no more business to be settled, I didn't end up hearing back from my QT question but it's sort of irrelevant at this point anyways.