WHO ARE THE REAL MONSTERS?!?!?!??!? MAFIA N5: nothing happened

Originally posted on MSPA by Agent1022.

---

So, the simplest model of the events surrounding Guy's murder, assuming that Pilot's busdrivering is correct, and Cat's mason-vig trolling was not, (and disregarding anything we lack testimony for, such as the interference of Doctor's, etc.) is this:

-excellent analysis snip-

But now, as tiredness threatens to overcome me, I think I've faltered at this hurdle of the investigation - I've got this far, but I'm stumped as to what this implies because my brain's being stupid.
I think possibly this implies that the murderising party would have tried to lynch either Tea or MrGuy, and we should investigate those bandwagons, but I'm not sure.
Does anyone have some insight they could lend me with this?

Your analyses impress me, Luneix, though I might point out that this points to them being both-town oh you know what even I don't believe that opposing forces theory anymore. There's just too much evidence against it; at least the inclination is that such a situation is unlikely. But just to check, let me see if the way I'm interpreting this is the same way you are:

Hypothesis One: Opposing Forces

Guy and Tea were on opposing forces (aka Tea is Scum).

Scum targets Tea.

Unless opposing Scum exists, not entirely likely, as you've mentioned. Just for the sake of completeness I'll mention the possibility that some neutral party/vigilante targeted Tea and that Mafia's kill was redirected (in some other capacity than 'targeting Guy' - can that even happen?) or nullified for some reason; it's not likely, of course, but it is a possible set of events. Those two kills then are transferred to Guy - although we still don't know if that's flavor. This is mafia by malky. We probably won't ever know. As Pilot says,

also having MrGuy killtargered twice (as some people noticed in the flavor although we believe flavor means jack shit) only works if two people targeted Tea anyways, which would probably be vig/mafia and that would make for one hell of a weird universe we're in

BUT THEN AGAIN THIS IS MAFIA BY MALKY (and fogel.)

also for completeness:

unless (somehow) there was a vig after Tea and the mafia after MrGuy and when I switched the kills it didn't do jack b/c Tea was/is doctored/bulletproof? doctor wouldn't work unless Guy was doctored but bulletproof is possible

Could happen, but then the universe starts to seem like it revolves around Tea and Guy. Weird universe indeed.

[font=system]
Process Agent1022: In Light of Process TehPilots claims about Process Tea, does your scan of process tea's behavior still return a report of infected?

Anyway, the point being, I have to admit that Tea being scum isn't really very likely in light of Pilot's assertion. Still, that's assuming Pilot's telling the truth, but it seems like no one's willing to come forward with evidence to back him up. Did no one else do anything to Tea or Guy that night?

Hypothesis Two: Town-Town

Guy and Tea are both Town.

-INVESTIGATION-

So I suppose I'm officially Unvote: A Killer Cuppa Tea. To be honest, I was debating whether to do that or wait to hear more in his defense - Tea's rebuttals still have been weak today so far, but the evidence is against his guilt at least as far as I can discern.

I HAD SOME OTHER THINGS HERE BUT I CAN'T REALLY GET MY THOUGHTS STRAIGHT AAAA ;∆;

QUESTION TIME!

now we don't think that we had a vigilante shoot that night? that kill was probably a mafia kill but we're not sure. tea is a weird target for a mafia kill. but I don't think there was more than one kill

wynaut

[quote=TehPilot]we see things pointing to tea as town and it isn't quite making sense (although we did suspect a Tea/Visceral town/town scenario this should not be such a shock)

did you

why

explain to me again i am tired

now we don't particularly like Solaris ourselves either since he's been off doing whatever and at this point i feel he should at least be saying words on this
[redacted to avoid screwing with the bot] until he pipes up [/color]

tell me more