Clue: Murder At Tudor Mansion [Killer Unmasked]

Straight West

Pick Yer Poison's turn. He rolls a 2.

I'm moving into the Ballroom.

I suggest Mr. Green, in the Ballroom, with a Candlestick.

Cannot disprove.

Image Update



Currently: Pick Yer Poison is making a suggestion: Mr Green in the Ballroom with the Candlestick.

soundlyParanoid is the next in line to state a capability or an inability to disprove the suggestion.

Hm. Okay, sP doesn't seem to be responding so I'll step in.

soundlyParanoid is unable to disprove the suggestion.

I can disprove it.

It is now Schazer's turn.

I remain in the ballroom, suggesting Miss Scarlett in the Ballroom with a spanner.

OH HELLO sorrryyyy.

It's a party in the ballroom!

Currently Schazer's turn. A suggestion has been made: Miss Scarlet in the Ballroom with the Spanner.

It is soundlyParanoid's turn to state a capability or an inability to disprove the suggestion.

I cannot disprove that suggestion.

I can disprove it.

soundlyParanoid's turn. A 5 is rolled.

Just a question for you all: would you prefer it if the can/cannot disprove bit of the game was just done by me? That might be faster, but it could be a bit odd. Your thoughts would be very much appreciated.

I think you should just skip anybody that can't disprove. If somebody can only disprove with one card and you automatically do it for them, you've just shown that the person only had one of those cards instead of a choice that you'd have to wait for.

Sounds good.

Pretty much what cyber said. Just make sure you tell us who you're skipping because you know they can't disprove the suggestion!

I reckon declaring as the mod who can't disprove is fine, but never auto-disprove.

Knowing somebody has two cards to choose from from a suggestion composed of three units is rather too useful to reveal by implication.

I'll step into the conservatory.

Mr. Scarlet, with the revolver, in the conservatory please.

Mr. Scarlet

I've got a hunch no one's going to have a card to disprove that one.

Pick Yer Poison can disprove the suggestion.

Isn't MalkyTop supposed to try it first? What happened to the turn order you have up at the start of the thread?

...or were none of the other people in the turn order able to disprove it?

I think that's right, PYP.
But yeah, It'd be helpful for clarity's sake just to mention explicitly that you're auto-disproving for which characters.