Murder By The Book - Ender's Game

Frankly I'm super annoyed that you'd even bring up the Chwoka argument. You and I both knew he was on vacation and wouldn't be able to adequately defend himself. Low blow.

Actually, though I made the mistake of not specifying, I was using your own definition of "fluff posters" in plural; Chwoka wasn't the only valid target (he just happened to quote and ask about it, so I answered him directly. He was intended to be one example, not the example). Erroneous omission, sure, but that still gives us Solaris, donut (who's active-ish but not in a useful way), Dalm, Gnauga, Mirdini, even Garuru and Akumu to some extent!

I'm not espousing an anti-lurker lynching philosophy, I'm espousing a scum or info lynching philosophy.

Something both you and Slorange are completely avoiding

If we get a lurker up to soft lynch and that makes them state some opinions, doesn't that give us at least half a wagon, more info, and net increased potential for more info down the track?

Like, do you think once we resolve the hot mess that is Eberron/Truegreen/Akumu/Slorange/Me/Sotek/You, those lurkers are going to step up and just start interacting for our collective lynchy benefit?

The way things are going, we'd be lucky to not need three more replacements by that point.

Actually, fuck it. Agentblue! You're going to need to poke your face in here sooner or later, so here's a question or two so when you start analysing the game so far, you can focus a bit better:

-What's your take on this debate between Granola and I? Do you think one of us is mafia? Do you think we're both town and being very clueless and silly?
-Look at Garuru's posts, and have a look at who mentions him in turn. Do you see any possible connections there? Who calls attention to their suspicious behaviour? Who tries to drive discussion away from them?
-For extra homework, do the same with Gnauga (I chose Garuru arbitrarily, honestly do it for as many people as you can manage. Heck, everyone try it for as many players as you can manage!)