RE: The Wander Island Incident - Day Two: Cold Dawn [18/21]
09-01-2018, 06:30 AM
(08-31-2018, 01:53 AM)Coldblooded Wrote: »(08-31-2018, 01:50 AM)awkwardcarapace Wrote: »Given that basically every player’s made some sort of comment on me and that I’ve been so entrenched in the discussion it would be helpful to town which way I flip, no? Do you not agree, considering your vote’s on me?
You already know which way you're going to flip though, what information are we supposed to gain from your death that YOU don't already have yourself?
It's not about what I think, but rather what everyone knows with undeniable evidence. Even if I do claim, there would be people who doubt - and with good reason - which would probably cause more confusion the ensuing moments after. It may be a fatalistic attitude but ultimately I think it's for the best (it's probably too late anyways)
Also - question time!
(09-01-2018, 02:33 AM)x1372 Wrote: »Ok. Since the day is going to end before I can really get a list of information questions to ask people ready, I'm just going to focus on awkwardcarapace.
At this point, I don't think anything is going to change with regard to you getting lynched. If you flip scum, well, good. If not, hopefully we can use this for information. So I've got a stupid long list of questions for you, please answer them to the best of your ability. IF THERE IS ANYTHING HERE THAT YOU THINK WOULD BE ANTI-TOWN TO ANSWER, PLEASE SAY SO INSTEAD WITH AN EXPLANATION.
1) Assume that exactly 3 people currently voting for you are scum. Who do you think they are, and why? If there were less than 3 scum targeting you, would that change your suspicions, and if so, to who?
2) Assuming you were alive tonight, and had the following one-shot powers, who would be your choices for the following night actions, and why would you select those players? Check, Protect, Kill, Track, Role-block, Watch. If you could do only one of these, which would you pick?
3) You have the ability to day kill one person who is NOT currently voting for you. Who do you pick, and why?
4) Assume Solaris is scum. Who do you suspect are their allies? Why?
5) What two players do you believe are most likely to be on opposite factions? Why?
6) Assume BlazerC is telling the truth and we decide to lynch them instead of you. You control their target. Do you aim for Numbers, your current vote? And if not, who do you target? Why?
7) We had a lot of nitty-gritty discussion about mechanics and strategy recently. Is there anything that you think we generally have WRONG that we should re-think going into day 3?
8) List, from most suspicious to least suspicious, all of the other players (Reyweld, Granolaman, TehPilot, BlazerC, Jacquerel, Solaris) who voted for LegendaryQ yesterday.
9) What four players are your top town reads, and why?
10) Do you have any other information or thoughts that you believe would be to the town's benefit going forward?
1) I'm gonna list just two because I think these guys are the most likely - 'nola and RL. But if i HAD to choose three my next pick would be seedy (not too confident in that one, though)
2) Check/watch/track Numbers - they said they had something in their role about worshipping some deity and I would be... interested in seeing what that even means
Questions 3) and 6) basically are "who would you kill had you the ability to" and to that I say people I feel totally middling about instead of people who I think (and other people) think are generally scum. That means NTA, Schazer or RL. I think this because eliminating ambiguity is more important than "proving they're scum" because we already have evidence/hunches against them
4) I'm not sure I can answer this question satisfactorily because if I assume Solaris is scum it throws my entire scumreads off - I'm thinking slight lean 3P rather than scum
5) Whoof, I REALLY do not have a good answer to this question either. There isn't a particular pair that just jumps out to me, and it wouldn't make much sense to list one of my townreads and one of my scumreads and say "oh they're opposed" so I'm going to pass on this one
7) Acio/x1372 is right in that it would make no sense for there to be a scum with a Hunter-like ability upon lynch, and thus no such role would actually exist
8) MOST <--- Granolaman -- TehPilot -- Solaris -- BlazerC -- Jacquerel ---> LEAST
DEAD: Reyweld
9) Jacq, Acio/x1372, CB, Sai - all people who've Make Good Posts as well as involving themselves in discussion that don't include them (a townplay for me)
10) Yes - I would get people to get BlazerC into posting more especially since that wild claim in post 426. They haven't been terribly active after considering a confirmed town, as they claim, so that kind of signals a "cool I'm safe now". Same goes for be ru ru, their post of reads I generally agree with but I would want to see more than that in the coming day (which will probably happen)
While I was writing this post...
(09-01-2018, 05:14 AM)TehPilot Wrote: »Vote: awkwardcarapace
Shall we end this?
omg hi hammerman