The Wander Island Incident - Night Four - Five For One [13/21]

Also why are you singling out Justice Watch's survival as suspect and not say, Slorange or anyone else?

Why are you singling out Blazer's nonmention of Slorange and not say, TehPilot or anyone else?

Why are you singling out CB's nonmention of TehPilot and not say,

What makes me in particular very towny? Can you give me some more detail?
That one's interesting to me because I posted very little on day one and was the last vote on the lynch which turned out to be a player which the scum team would not have known wasn't town, at a very late hour where people wouldn't be able to react to it.
What makes Airey scum, and what's the difference between your read on Slorange and your read on Schazer?

In general your posts have been pretty lengthy/comprehensive (as have Sai's + Acio's), you've dipped your toe into many different conversations and you generally seem to have an aura of "I know what I'm doing" about you. The fact that you appeared late in the game doesn't matter as much to me because you were active then and are active now - it's all good in my book.

Airey I did not look favorable upon because of their insistence of pushing a D1 lynch upon slorange, as well as the general Shitpost Aura surrounding them (coupled with the fact that they didn't post too much) - it does not make me very confident in their town-ness, seems kind of sketch
(Also, after rereading I'm going to reconsider and upgrade slorange to Ambiguityland. This is because of, well, see above - I realize now it wouldn't make much sense if one scum member was trying to accuse another of chickening out on a lynch in public, and the fact that they didn't post much in D1 either muddles the issue further)
I know that those reads probably seem backward to a lot of you guys 'cause "trying to dodge a D1 lynch is a more scum move" and insisting a lynch is more productive town-wise... but, ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ it's what I think at least, and I don't feel extremely strongly about these particular reads!

Schaz - originally I was like "well that's not very helpful" in regards to the D1 Is Bad posts so the read was not positive at the time, but I'm willing to accept that she may be a bit towny because later on near the tail end of the Day she seemed to commit more (which she actually said in her own post). Whether this will actually be followed through with remains to be seen! I will say her ambiguous and kind of sparse posts past a certain point put her in jeapordy of being in Ambiguityland, though. Bias against BlazerC does kind of put her slightly in favor though, lmao

Explain in further detail please. Start with the Q wagon if nothing else.

Oh yeah, that thing. Practically nobody knew Q's true identity, which kind of makes this a grab bag of votes. Early voters were jokes (Reyweld, Granola), which I'll disregard. That leaves TehPilot, Blazer, Jacq, Solaris and me. TehPilot's vote seems... like... almost entirely out of the blue? Their post surrounding it is only tangientally related to the vote, too. Sussy. Blease post more

Feeling fine about the rest of the people on the wagon since they Craved Information and a lynch. It still kind of surprises me the Q lynch ended up happening, not totally sure how it all came together like that. Life works in mysterious ways

aC now focusing on the whys of Justice Watch because of Blazer is almost as weird as watching Blazer focus on it.

Also, if you feel like everything Blazer is doing is super suspicious, and you can't really justify why it makes sense as town, why do you have them as a townish read instead of, you know, voting for them? Is it literally just because town infighting is likely to happen in these games?

The cycle of jwatch never ends...! Maybe this was their plan all along, to cause all this commotion (by posting NOTHING!!!!!)

If you couldn't tell already I'm a very Wait-And-See kind of player so I'm Waiting and Seeing - the hunch is there, it's just not super strong enough yet. (And yes, town infighting is a factor too.)

[shuffling papers, wiping brow] ...whew!