RE: Murder By The Book - Day 5: The Rings of Satire
05-03-2014, 05:51 AM
Even disregarding the pie entirely, Sotek and Pala were both fairly major players on two scum lynches in a row, and have been acting generally protown besides that. So I'm comfortable calling both of them town for now.
Except that that's not even remotely what I was saying at all? There are a whole lot of people that look townish right now for a wide variety of reasons. And the list of town looking people just so happens to match up almost exactly with the list of non-lurkers.
You giving a passing defense of Truegreen on D3 is not what's scummy, what's scummy is the fact that he's one of the few people you mention in both of your two readwalls up to that point, (once calling him suspicious and then ignoring him to go throw your vote on Mirdini, and the second time calling him townish) but then not even posting at all for the entire day yesterday when he and Eberron were going up against each other.
Remember earlier when I said that I suspected scum of hiding off in the background yesterday, getting ready to throw a vote on Eberron at the last minute before Donut could show up and claim? Hi there Agent. (To be fair I'm not sure whether or not you have a good excuse for not posting yesterday, but I don't remember hearing about it if there was one.)
No, talking and defending yourself are not scummy actions on their own at all, but having a huge, unprovoked jump in activity immediately after two scum members have been lynched in a row is. It sort of indicates that your thought process is somewhere along the lines of "Oh dang, our most active scummate just died! Guess somebody better go pick up the slack for them there, huh?"
Alternately, somebody else on your team warned you last you last night that today was going to be open season on all lurkers, so you should probably get out ahead of the pack and all that.
As a side note, you're acting awfully defensive for having only a single vote on you right now. Maybe try toning that down just a bit.
_____________________________________________________
Anyways, I'm leaving to go to my cousin's wedding in Michigan tomorrow morning, so I might be posting sparsely for the next day and a half or so. In the meantime, I would still very much like to hear from all the other people on the orange list up there.
(05-02-2014, 03:05 PM)AgentBlue Wrote: »I'd like to point out that Coldblooded's argument regarding "green not wanting to lynch lurkers = lurkers is scum = Agen is scum" is flawed;
Except that that's not even remotely what I was saying at all? There are a whole lot of people that look townish right now for a wide variety of reasons. And the list of town looking people just so happens to match up almost exactly with the list of non-lurkers.
(05-02-2014, 03:05 PM)AgentBlue Wrote: »Not to mention that you're parlaying your defence of green into proof of your innocence, whereas apparently my defence of him proves my guilt.
ô_ò
You giving a passing defense of Truegreen on D3 is not what's scummy, what's scummy is the fact that he's one of the few people you mention in both of your two readwalls up to that point, (once calling him suspicious and then ignoring him to go throw your vote on Mirdini, and the second time calling him townish) but then not even posting at all for the entire day yesterday when he and Eberron were going up against each other.
Remember earlier when I said that I suspected scum of hiding off in the background yesterday, getting ready to throw a vote on Eberron at the last minute before Donut could show up and claim? Hi there Agent. (To be fair I'm not sure whether or not you have a good excuse for not posting yesterday, but I don't remember hearing about it if there was one.)
(05-02-2014, 03:05 PM)AgentBlue Wrote: »(05-02-2014, 05:02 AM)Coldblooded Wrote: »And then they come in early today and start posting up a relative storm immediately after an incredibly talkative scum agent kicks the bucket. That's uh... kind of a textbook scumtell?
So now if I keep talking/try to defend myself I'm obviously the new green, right? Or if I'm silent I'm obviously the new green, right? Nice Morton's fork you've got there.
No, talking and defending yourself are not scummy actions on their own at all, but having a huge, unprovoked jump in activity immediately after two scum members have been lynched in a row is. It sort of indicates that your thought process is somewhere along the lines of "Oh dang, our most active scummate just died! Guess somebody better go pick up the slack for them there, huh?"
Alternately, somebody else on your team warned you last you last night that today was going to be open season on all lurkers, so you should probably get out ahead of the pack and all that.
As a side note, you're acting awfully defensive for having only a single vote on you right now. Maybe try toning that down just a bit.
_____________________________________________________
Anyways, I'm leaving to go to my cousin's wedding in Michigan tomorrow morning, so I might be posting sparsely for the next day and a half or so. In the meantime, I would still very much like to hear from all the other people on the orange list up there.