RE: Murder By The Book - Day 5: The Rings of Satire
05-02-2014, 05:02 AM
Alright, I know that a lot of people were talking about how they didn't like me for defending Truegreen yesterday, which is fair, but let's step back and examine that for a moment. If I was scum with Truegreen, then presumably I would have also already known for a fact that Donut, Akumu, and Ebberon were all town. And in that case, Donut hyper-defending the two of them while straight up refusing to give any reasoning for his reads at all becomes an almost absurdly obvious info-role claim. (As an aside, I did sort of suspect Donut of being cop for awhile yesterday, but ended up throwing that thought out because "no way could he possibly be that bad of a cop.)
Now, my question is, if I was scum with Truegreen, why in the world would I show up to defend him out of nowhere and then immediately start pressuring the exact people that would ensure an early Donut claim, and thus seal Truegreen's fate while simultaneously making myself look a lot worse?
As opposed to, say, continuing to lurk under the (true) excuse that I hadn't finished rereading yet, probably tossing a vote on Ebberon at the last minute, and then just quietly killing Donut in the night before he could claim? Hell, if Truegreen lived, he could have even been janitored/kidnapped instead.
Anyway, this is also another reason why I don't really suspect there of being any scum on the Donut wagon yesterday, (though Sotek, Pala, and Seedy were already doing a fine job of looking townish even before then), and another yet reason why I suspect that most/all of the non-Truegreen scum were lurking yesterday.
__________________________________
I finished re-reading last night, and my current reads list looks something like this:
__________________________________
Which brings me to my final point, AgentBlue.
AgentBlue has been pretty much powerlurking throughout the entire game so far, only giving out the bare minimum of opinions to avoid having votes thrown their way. They don't post anything at all throughout the first half of Day 2, but are apparently still paying attention enough to the thread to respond within an hour of getting prodded by Schazer. I'm not exactly sure what to make of their one and only D3 post, where they call Truegreen town and Slorange/Schazer/Garuru as all 3rd party, but whatever it is I don't really like it.
And then they come in early today and start posting up a relative storm immediately after an incredibly talkative scum agent kicks the bucket. That's uh... kind of a textbook scumtell?
Anyways Agent, I know you just starting talking recently, but if you could keep doing that, that would be much appreciated. In fact if everyone in the orange section could share their opinions so far, especially about the other members of the orange group, that would be fantastic.
For now though,
Lynch AgentBlue.
Now, my question is, if I was scum with Truegreen, why in the world would I show up to defend him out of nowhere and then immediately start pressuring the exact people that would ensure an early Donut claim, and thus seal Truegreen's fate while simultaneously making myself look a lot worse?
As opposed to, say, continuing to lurk under the (true) excuse that I hadn't finished rereading yet, probably tossing a vote on Ebberon at the last minute, and then just quietly killing Donut in the night before he could claim? Hell, if Truegreen lived, he could have even been janitored/kidnapped instead.
Anyway, this is also another reason why I don't really suspect there of being any scum on the Donut wagon yesterday, (though Sotek, Pala, and Seedy were already doing a fine job of looking townish even before then), and another yet reason why I suspect that most/all of the non-Truegreen scum were lurking yesterday.
__________________________________
I finished re-reading last night, and my current reads list looks something like this:
Which brings me to my final point, AgentBlue.
AgentBlue has been pretty much powerlurking throughout the entire game so far, only giving out the bare minimum of opinions to avoid having votes thrown their way. They don't post anything at all throughout the first half of Day 2, but are apparently still paying attention enough to the thread to respond within an hour of getting prodded by Schazer. I'm not exactly sure what to make of their one and only D3 post, where they call Truegreen town and Slorange/Schazer/Garuru as all 3rd party, but whatever it is I don't really like it.
And then they come in early today and start posting up a relative storm immediately after an incredibly talkative scum agent kicks the bucket. That's uh... kind of a textbook scumtell?
Anyways Agent, I know you just starting talking recently, but if you could keep doing that, that would be much appreciated. In fact if everyone in the orange section could share their opinions so far, especially about the other members of the orange group, that would be fantastic.
For now though,
Lynch AgentBlue.