RE: Murder By The Book - Day 4: Life of Pie
04-26-2014, 04:39 PM
I have to be honest, donut, you've done shit for arguing why eberron is town. Assuming you're telling the truth, you got your investigation report back and called it a day. Your defense of eberron since then has been "he's town, he's town, he's town, I say so, he's town." Why is godfather less likely than town? Factoring in Solaris's day one rescue, of course.
Roleclaiming as cop seems like a death sentence. It seems like all anti-town parties are going to want donut dead tonight and if at all possible janitored. Either to stop them from investigating further, if it's true, or to leave the claims sitting out there confusing things if it's false. If we lynch donut now we can be sure that they won't be janitored and we can solidly know if they were a cop or not.
On the other hand, if we lynch him and he is a cop, I would think that almost certainly me or eberron would be night-killed the following night. I'd rather not be killed, especially in a way that gives no new information to the town!
So the running theories for me right now are:
1) Eberron is godfather
2) Eberron and donut are both Undercover
3) Every person who is active today is town, there were competing lynch mobs right off the bat to lynch Truegreen or eberron, both town, and all of Undercover is sitting back and laughing their asses off.
Roleclaiming as cop seems like a death sentence. It seems like all anti-town parties are going to want donut dead tonight and if at all possible janitored. Either to stop them from investigating further, if it's true, or to leave the claims sitting out there confusing things if it's false. If we lynch donut now we can be sure that they won't be janitored and we can solidly know if they were a cop or not.
On the other hand, if we lynch him and he is a cop, I would think that almost certainly me or eberron would be night-killed the following night. I'd rather not be killed, especially in a way that gives no new information to the town!
So the running theories for me right now are:
1) Eberron is godfather
2) Eberron and donut are both Undercover
3) Every person who is active today is town, there were competing lynch mobs right off the bat to lynch Truegreen or eberron, both town, and all of Undercover is sitting back and laughing their asses off.