RE: Murder By The Book - Day 3: The Book of Revelation
04-12-2014, 08:44 PM
First off, can I just explain what's with the "everyone" "only 2 people" vote thing. I realize I should have explained it way back, but it didn't seem important enough at the time.
Eberron was very nearly lynched D1. No info happened N1. Then two people voted, both of whom I was suspicious of. Nobody retracted their desire to lynch Eberron at some point. Thus, it was still a popular option at the time. Did I overexaggerate? Maybe. Did I find anyone scummy, other than Soteknola? Not really. I said I "was annoyed", not that I wanted to lynch the people voting Eberron. So I don't get why people are voting me solely because of that?
Here, have a quote:
Basically, I was saying that most people (aside from Soteknola) could either be scum or town. The wagon just kind of irked me for non-game-related reasons. Thus, it wasn't important to point out specific people on the wagon, because they knew who they were.
Reads:
town
slightly town
null
slightly scum
scum
1. Mirdini - Totally town (thanks, power play). Sadly, dying. Reads have all been cool.
2. Whimbrel - Oh no not another lurker.
3. SleepingOrange - Eeeehhhhh. Never really felt good about him all game, what with his obsession on his own (could be either town or scum) claim (misdirecting town maybe), and not really scumhunting much otherwise, but also don't really WANT to lynch him today. Maybe later?
4. Garuru - Um, like the best player, gosh.
5. Schazer - Meh. Also ambivalent. Wouldn't mind lynching. Doesn't seem to be pushing enough weight for her activeness? It's all been mechanics-heavy, and not very scumhunt-y.
6. Sotek - much too quiet, but apparently he isn't all that interested in the game, so. Null.
7. icanhasdonut - did he say anything of value? i cant really remember him doing anything.
8. Akumu - kind of dropped off the face of the planet once seedy let up.
9. seedy - Okay. Some tunneling, but town generally.
10. Palamedes - Pops in and out, nice posts.
11. Nova - This was a toughie, because he just seems so contrary and aggressive. However, that's kind of a good thing I think, and I don't see much other reason to lynch him.
12. eberron - Okay, despite all my defending him D1-ish (mainly because he's new, I'll admit), I am more than okay with an eberron lynch today. He pretty much stopped posting once focus drifted away from him (big tell), and hasn't really been super helpful since.
13. AgentBlue - that latest post of theirs has me going hmm, because of the weird "tentative town, third party, third party" reads. Maybe give some concrete scumreads?
14. Truegreen - I've been feeling meh about him the whole game, because he has also been very mechanics-driven and not very scumhunty. Also, he tries so very hard to debunk Slorange's claim, which Slorry already admitted could be read either town or scum, so shouldn't even be all that important in the long run. Then there's that vote for me, and that addendum referring to another player's post with 0 original thought, when accused of not explaining reasons for voting. Then again, maybe I am just taking it personally. I tend to not like when people hop on a wagon voting me without much reason. Seems, kind of rude, I dunno? Regardless, scum.
15. Dalm - Is trying her best. I actually do like her reads, though, she should keep them up.
16. bigro - null
18. Chwoka - null
19. Gnauga - Felt kind of town-ish to me. More like they don't trip any of my scumhunty triggers.
21. Solaris - Tends to plop a few votes here and there then not really do much to back them up. I wouldn't mind lynching them as well, but not as much as the likes of Truegreen or eberron.
To summarize:
Possible scum from least scummy to most: Slorange, donut, Schazer, Solaris, Akumu, eberron, Truegreen.
Not aligned: Truegreen/Slorange, Truegreen/eberron
Aligned: Schazer/Slorange
That's all I can think of in terms of alignments. I'm not that great at that kind of stuff.
Eberron was very nearly lynched D1. No info happened N1. Then two people voted, both of whom I was suspicious of. Nobody retracted their desire to lynch Eberron at some point. Thus, it was still a popular option at the time. Did I overexaggerate? Maybe. Did I find anyone scummy, other than Soteknola? Not really. I said I "was annoyed", not that I wanted to lynch the people voting Eberron. So I don't get why people are voting me solely because of that?
Here, have a quote:
(03-29-2014, 10:43 PM)Garuru Wrote: »Still really annoyed by people pushing very hard for an eberron lynch, but I will admit he does look kind of scummy right now, from kind of flip-flopping between convictions. My vibe is telling me that he's town, trying his best to cover for his early mistakes. I feel like everyone pushing for eberron is trying too hard to have a lynch today, though whether it's a mislynch or an information lynch probably depends on the person voting. Honestly, eberron is the ULTRA PRIME #1 info lynch, because of the ridiculous number of people attacking or supporting him, so even then, there's not much to go on, at least until Eberron flips, if he does get lynched/killed.
Basically, I was saying that most people (aside from Soteknola) could either be scum or town. The wagon just kind of irked me for non-game-related reasons. Thus, it wasn't important to point out specific people on the wagon, because they knew who they were.
Reads:
town
slightly town
null
slightly scum
scum
1. Mirdini - Totally town (thanks, power play). Sadly, dying. Reads have all been cool.
2. Whimbrel - Oh no not another lurker.
3. SleepingOrange - Eeeehhhhh. Never really felt good about him all game, what with his obsession on his own (could be either town or scum) claim (misdirecting town maybe), and not really scumhunting much otherwise, but also don't really WANT to lynch him today. Maybe later?
4. Garuru - Um, like the best player, gosh.
5. Schazer - Meh. Also ambivalent. Wouldn't mind lynching. Doesn't seem to be pushing enough weight for her activeness? It's all been mechanics-heavy, and not very scumhunt-y.
6. Sotek - much too quiet, but apparently he isn't all that interested in the game, so. Null.
7. icanhasdonut - did he say anything of value? i cant really remember him doing anything.
8. Akumu - kind of dropped off the face of the planet once seedy let up.
9. seedy - Okay. Some tunneling, but town generally.
10. Palamedes - Pops in and out, nice posts.
11. Nova - This was a toughie, because he just seems so contrary and aggressive. However, that's kind of a good thing I think, and I don't see much other reason to lynch him.
12. eberron - Okay, despite all my defending him D1-ish (mainly because he's new, I'll admit), I am more than okay with an eberron lynch today. He pretty much stopped posting once focus drifted away from him (big tell), and hasn't really been super helpful since.
13. AgentBlue - that latest post of theirs has me going hmm, because of the weird "tentative town, third party, third party" reads. Maybe give some concrete scumreads?
14. Truegreen - I've been feeling meh about him the whole game, because he has also been very mechanics-driven and not very scumhunty. Also, he tries so very hard to debunk Slorange's claim, which Slorry already admitted could be read either town or scum, so shouldn't even be all that important in the long run. Then there's that vote for me, and that addendum referring to another player's post with 0 original thought, when accused of not explaining reasons for voting. Then again, maybe I am just taking it personally. I tend to not like when people hop on a wagon voting me without much reason. Seems, kind of rude, I dunno? Regardless, scum.
15. Dalm - Is trying her best. I actually do like her reads, though, she should keep them up.
16. bigro - null
18. Chwoka - null
19. Gnauga - Felt kind of town-ish to me. More like they don't trip any of my scumhunty triggers.
21. Solaris - Tends to plop a few votes here and there then not really do much to back them up. I wouldn't mind lynching them as well, but not as much as the likes of Truegreen or eberron.
To summarize:
Possible scum from least scummy to most: Slorange, donut, Schazer, Solaris, Akumu, eberron, Truegreen.
Not aligned: Truegreen/Slorange, Truegreen/eberron
Aligned: Schazer/Slorange
That's all I can think of in terms of alignments. I'm not that great at that kind of stuff.