RE: Murder By The Book - Day 2: The Invisible Man
03-31-2014, 04:38 AM
(03-31-2014, 03:38 AM)Schazer Wrote: »Erroneous omission, sure, but that still gives us Solaris, donut (who's active-ish but not in a useful way), Dalm, Gnauga, Mirdini, even Garuru and Akumu to some extent!
[...]
You're going to need to poke your face in here sooner or later, so here's a question or two so when you start analysing the game so far, you can focus a bit better:
-What's your take on this debate between Granola and I? Do you think one of us is mafia? Do you think we're both town and being very clueless and silly?
-Look at Garuru's posts, and have a look at who mentions him in turn. Do you see any possible connections there? Who calls attention to their suspicious behaviour? Who tries to drive discussion away from them?
-For extra homework, do the same with Gnauga (I chose Garuru arbitrarily, honestly do it for as many people as you can manage. Heck, everyone try it for as many players as you can manage!)
everyone who Schazer listed should be answering these
Also uh, I guess for people voting Slorange I'd ask what you think happened with cyber and why the mafia chose him of all people. And also why Slorange chose to explicitly stablish that cyber could have been any alignment while making his claim. Hmm, I guess if you wanted to really go out on a limb you could say the latter might tangentially be seen as making sure Schazer's speedlynch push wasn't seen in a bad light.
But I don't really see mafia claiming with no pressure on them for little reason. Weird unprovable claims are really likely to get the claimant lynched. They're not a ticket to townfirmed heaven as granola seems to be implying.
Also dang, I was feeling neutral about granola until Schaz's postmining reminded me of that time he said we should lynch Chwoka "for info." What was up with that?
As long as we're talking about "lynching inactive players" and "lynching people who will actually give us info" I'd like to point out that Akumu is in a tangled web of interactions and also hasn't made a post that consists of more than a few responses to my increasingly frenzied exhortations in 3 goddamn days.
Seriously. They're paying enough attention to answer my questions but haven't done anything else. If that's not scummy behavior then I don't know what is.