Murder By The Book - Ender's Game

I don't like that you're focusing on me, because you seem to be judging me by your standards of play, instead of any sort of analysis dealing with whether or not I am scum. Conversely, I'm not going to turn around and vote for you based on your style of play.

Uh, vaguely throwing suspicion and not backing up things with votes or solid accusations of players is a scumtell? I'm not saying you're scum because you're not driving hard after people, I'm saying you're scum because you're barely driving anywhere. You're pretty much active lurking.
You don't need to be uber-suspicious of someone to back it up with a vote. But if you can't find anyone scummy enough to kill yet then you should actually, y'know, pressure the people you find scummy.
My 'standards of play' happen to involve actually lynching people...which you seemed to be sooo into yesterday? 'Math' isn't a good enough reason to flip-flop from "I will kill literally anyone" to "I don't want to kill anyone right now." Also the reasons you'd have to vote me aren't my playstyle, it's the fact that I helped no lynch/save someone you wanted dead. Both of these should be incredibly scummy actions from your perspective and based on what you've said! But you're completely uninterested in going after I or anyone else who did similar things. Your words and actions aren't matching up. That's scummy.
I'm voting you because (with the exception of voting eberron) your words are vague and your actions are non-existent. If that happens to be your playstyle then it's an incredibly scummy one that does little to further the game. I have never played with you to my recollection so uh...I can't really take your claim of that for granted.

-Huh, I don't think a janitor-kill'd be that weird? granola, I think your point about where Slorange chose to nexus things to only makes sense if you can prove that there was a target Slorange logically should have preferred. I mean, if he didn't think eberron was town, then yeah...but if he did then he doesn't really seem the type to nexus some poor bugger just for info? Hmm, I don't honestly remember Slorange strongly voicing suspicions of much of anyone yesterday, but that might just be because he wasn't voting so it's less noticeable. Besides, if he's scum then you pretty much have to assume eberron is scum. Because making a contentious player completely disappear so that we have no idea what the fuck happened with that wagon and then claiming it was the work of an uninformed townie so that we get zilch out of it would be too delicious to pass up in favor of killing a decent mislynch candidate. (Before any objections: there'd be better kill choices but not many that'd let Slorange claim he was town doing town things)
Anyways I was feeling weird about Sotek but his explanation of his actions makes some sense...we really need more people voting in here. On the other hand, you've played in multiple mafias with 8 people here and only talked about a few of us, so I'm not sure that aspect of what you said holds water. But I respect being busy.

Still really annoyed by people pushing very hard for an eberron lynch, but I will admit he does look kind of scummy right now, from kind of flip-flopping between convictions. My vibe is telling me that he's town, trying his best to cover for his early mistakes. I feel like everyone pushing for eberron is trying too hard to have a lynch today, though whether it's a mislynch or an information lynch probably depends on the person voting. Honestly, eberron is the ULTRA PRIME #1 info lynch, because of the ridiculous number of people attacking or supporting him, so even then, there's not much to go on, at least until Eberron flips, if he does get lynched/killed.

eberron - 2 (Sotek, Granolaman)

'everyone'


I mean, I'm sure that there are/were people advocating it who aren't voting...but the only people you've actually mentioned is a crowd of 2.

Hmm, I thought I didn't like Pala, but on re-glance he's actually alright. Truegreen and bigro both seem town. Eberron keeps Requesting Death but how I feel about people's reactions to them keeps absolving them. Schazer feels iffy to me. Dalm could do with posting a little more because right now where they are and what they're doing feels off.