Tropefia - A PYP - N5: Downed Guy (11/24) (need replacement)

MYW, there's no evidence that you actually got hit by anyone. It wasn't announced that you survived a kill in daystart.

how do we know you're not lying scum cashing in on not taking a shot last night, hmm?

WRT 2create, gonna be honest here: His ability was to "permanently give up his vote for a permanent BP"

HIS POWER WAS TO STUMP HIMSELF

by definition, stumps don't count towards the vote total
even if he used his power, it wouldn't count towards "number of town maf have to kill to win the game" because all maf has to do is CONTROL THE VOTE. They don't have to kill until there are only x number of town alive, as long as they control the vote unanimously, town loses.

Therefore the fact that we actually DID lynch him is kind of a good thing in some ways: If 2create had activated his power and stumped himself, then we had mislynched PW instead (who apparently was also town and a nexus that didn't work on kills so... uhhhh yeah), and scum and the vampire shot people who weren't MYW/ scum actually shot if MYW is lying scum; then we'd actually be down 4 town, effectively.

:/

So in order for me to be scum, you think scum gave up a free kill to introduce me as a fake town?
It's not implausible, but like... any investigation or anything would waste that effort, and then the town basically wasted a free kill.

and it wouldn't come up in the day's news what happened to me because it would be much too informative.

I'm not feeling you're town, red, since that's a really strange leap in logic.

And yeah, I guess 2create's ability was pretty pointless, but if he could trick scum into killing him once it would be useful. Lynching him didn't actually help anything either.

Actually, it did help one thing- the scum figured I was town or some kinda mason for some reason (just because I wanted 2create to roleclaim to keep himself alive/give everyone else some information)
so they shot me, and wasted their night kill.

Mass claiming != claiming, and is in no way necessarily caused by it.

I do think myw jumped the gun, but in most situations if you are about to eat a lynch and are a powerful (or provable) town role you should claim. Either you prove yourself or get some results, or the mafia is forced to spend their kill on you, as opposed to, I don't know, town using up a lynch when they could potentially be lynching scum instead.

I don't think I jumped a gun, because
1) my power is useless now
2) scum know I am bulletproof, since I'm clearly not dead and I think they might have gotten a notification
3) we lost our bodyguard and doctor(?) so thats not the reason why I'm not dead
4) If scum know I'm just the bulletproof, everyone else might as well know that one too

I'm also claiming so you guys all know I'm town.
Alright, not KNOW I'm town, but honestly I think my reasoning is pretty sound. I made like 4 lists explaining myself and everything. I think I earned at least some kinda psuedo clear.