-=- Crooks Hollow III Mafia -=- Day Five? (3/21)

I think cali saying mathgirl is town is a pretty weak reason to kill her. I mean, he could have just tossed a town player into his reads, and I'm pretty sure everyone was ganging up on 0_o at the time. If I had to choose between Scoffles and Mathgirl, I'd pick Scoffles.

"Rubber bullets" just seems like a pretty weak claim. It keeps you out of suivig territory, and you get the checkmark for having made a claim. The real issue I see with it, is that we have yet to see any roles that are purely weakening roles. None of the roles presented so far have had this effect. I call bs.

TehPilot offing Cali and revealing him as scum pretty much removed any doubts I've had about Mirdini being town, since he made the call-to-arms.

I think we may have two deaths tomorrow (because that janitor role is still out there)

Mechanically I still feel like Coldblooded is particularly town.

but now I'm just stating random facts.

KILLING MATHGIRL:

If she is scum:
- Aids the "town-ness" of several players, including Coldblooded, Mirdini, Acionyx
- The scum can no longer call a gun-ban.

If she is town:
- Places new suspicions on players who harped for her lynch.
- We lose a gunban role.
- Must re-evaluate theories about early game role discussions. (though, really have these been that helpful in the first place?)

KILLING SCOFFLES:

If he's town:
- Reaffirms suspicions on Acio
- We lose a role that can't even suicidevig

If he's scum:
- Strongly boosts Acionyx's "town-i-ness"
- scum could have a role that has rubber bullets too (if that is his role)