RE: Tropefia - A PYP - D2: Milk Stains (21/24)
06-01-2013, 12:50 AM
Sure Walrus. I suspect Calibornio more now because he had four people noted as scummy and two of them were the people who were voting for him early today. It seems strange, specially since no one else really suspects palamendes.
Also, his reasoning about me being scum kinda...eh. This line, specifically "They were lurking all of D1 and then they spend most of D2 trying to get 2create to roleclaim for no reason other than because he’s gonna die anyway. Which means myw probably doesn’t think 2create is scum because otherwise they wouldn’t care whether or not 2create dies" Isn't sound at all, because he's trying to paint my wanting information out of a player who's about to die as negative, somehow.
Why would extra information ever hurt, where's the benefit
If he told us his role, we could use that information along side him dying to I dunno, know more things. It doesn't make sense to consider extra information a scum trait.
So yeah, basically. the analysis feels forced.
Also, his reasoning about me being scum kinda...eh. This line, specifically "They were lurking all of D1 and then they spend most of D2 trying to get 2create to roleclaim for no reason other than because he’s gonna die anyway. Which means myw probably doesn’t think 2create is scum because otherwise they wouldn’t care whether or not 2create dies" Isn't sound at all, because he's trying to paint my wanting information out of a player who's about to die as negative, somehow.
Why would extra information ever hurt, where's the benefit
If he told us his role, we could use that information along side him dying to I dunno, know more things. It doesn't make sense to consider extra information a scum trait.
So yeah, basically. the analysis feels forced.