RE: Tropefia - A PYP - D2: Milk Stains (21/24)
05-31-2013, 10:42 PM
So yeah, here’s my reads so far.
MrGuy- seems pretty towny, but it is kind of weird that he keeps questioning Pilot. I guess it sort of makes sense with Pilot’s grannyclaim nonsense, but at least half of Guy’s posts have been about Pilot, which is pretty unusual, considering there are a lot of other people he could question.
Konec0- seems really towny for his good arguments against the catlynch and for voting 2create. Should post more, though.
Mirdini- seems pretty towny to me, but he always does, so I have no idea if he’s really town or just experienced scum. Most likely town this game, though.
LeafViata- They also seem pretty town to me, especially for a replacement and especially for their myw reads, as I found those pretty suspicious as well. Also, their reads on Pala look towny as well.
Yd12k- They seem pretty scummy to me so far. They only have a few posts and most of them seem pretty suspicious. First, they start off with voting PW, which isn’t necessarily scummy, but then they don’t really post again until 2 days later saying they had meant to post something the day before, but it didn’t really make it and then they don’t really explain what the post was about. Then, they don’t post again until the next (in-game) day and only really focus on myw voting me. So yeah, yd12k is scummy and they need to post more.
Scoffles- They seemed to be really against catlynch and really for PWlynch, and had good reasons for both, so I see them as neutral atm because I don’t agree with their reads and votes, but I admit that the votes didn’t come out of nowhere. Need to post more.
Garuru- Their comments on cyber’s roleclaim look town because I also thought it was weird that everybody was upset with cyber for claiming. I mean, how could he have hid his power, it’s pretty obvious? And the rest of their posts seem pretty towny as well.
Cyber- Most of his early posts centered around his doublevoting, so not much there, although his power is most likely town. I would like to know more about why he changed his mind about 2create, tough. So mostly towny for him.
FelixSparks, seastorm, mathgirl- You guys need to post more. Stop lurking.
Kiven- Seems neutral with a very slight townread. He said a lot of the things a lot of other people were saying about 2create, but it didn’t feel like sheeping. And he gave some reads, but I feel he could do more, maybe post more.
Myw- scummy scum, although they might be 3rd party or just have a special role. They were lurking all of D1 and then they spend most of D2 trying to get 2create to roleclaim for no reason other than because he’s gonna die anyway. Which means myw probably doesn’t think 2create is scum because otherwise they wouldn’t care whether or not 2create dies. My guess is either:
1. myw is scumbuddies with 2create and doesn’t want them to die, and so is trying to make it seem like they are against 2create and make 2create roleclaim.
2. same as above, except with masons (less likely).
3. myw suspects 2create is a certain role and wants to see if their guess is true because they need that role for something.
Either way, myw doesn’t look good.
Gnauga- Seems pretty neutral, he focused on 2create being catwagon scum, which is plausible, and cyber trying to get everyone on redwagon, which is slightly less plausible.
2create- At first I thought they were derpscum because of the catwagon vote, but then they seemed more like derptown because they were doing everything town told them to do and offered themselves as a lynch, not to mention the whole myw roleclaim debacle. They could still be scumbuddies with myw, though.
Pilot- Pilot looks kinda scummy imo. First, he kept grannyclaiming, which wasn’t very useful. Next, he said he was fine with catlynch, but didn’t like how Mirdini wasn’t saying anything else except catlynch, which gave off some bad vibes, but not too bad of vibes. Then he said he was gonna look at me/credit/pw, but he hasn’t done that yet. So slight scumlean.
Red- They seem pretty town and have posted a lot, been petty active. They could easily be scum pretending to be town (especially with all the “EVEN Q HAS POSTED MORE THAN YOU GUYS” posts), but I doubt it.
Pala- Pala looks pretty scummy this game as well. He didn’t seem very helpful in the beginning and his support of myw and 2create didn’t look very good either, especially since he later changed his mind about 2create seemingly out of nowhere. Explanations please.
PW- He seems like derptown imo. The redvote didn’t seem very suspicious to me and I thought his wagon looked pretty scummy and came out of nowhere so I defended him. Then he gave some good opinions on yd12k and why he was voting myw. And finally he sealed the deal with not realizing that Dini didn’t have to unvote before voting again. This could all be an act, though.
ICGranola- Pretty neutral about Credit. Partially meta because I know he likes to play meta like a clown, so I don’t question the sillier stuff he does. Also, him pointing out cyber as doublevoter didn’t really seem that bad to me because it would’ve been pretty obvious anyway. Not so sure about granola yet.
MrGuy- seems pretty towny, but it is kind of weird that he keeps questioning Pilot. I guess it sort of makes sense with Pilot’s grannyclaim nonsense, but at least half of Guy’s posts have been about Pilot, which is pretty unusual, considering there are a lot of other people he could question.
Konec0- seems really towny for his good arguments against the catlynch and for voting 2create. Should post more, though.
Mirdini- seems pretty towny to me, but he always does, so I have no idea if he’s really town or just experienced scum. Most likely town this game, though.
LeafViata- They also seem pretty town to me, especially for a replacement and especially for their myw reads, as I found those pretty suspicious as well. Also, their reads on Pala look towny as well.
Yd12k- They seem pretty scummy to me so far. They only have a few posts and most of them seem pretty suspicious. First, they start off with voting PW, which isn’t necessarily scummy, but then they don’t really post again until 2 days later saying they had meant to post something the day before, but it didn’t really make it and then they don’t really explain what the post was about. Then, they don’t post again until the next (in-game) day and only really focus on myw voting me. So yeah, yd12k is scummy and they need to post more.
Scoffles- They seemed to be really against catlynch and really for PWlynch, and had good reasons for both, so I see them as neutral atm because I don’t agree with their reads and votes, but I admit that the votes didn’t come out of nowhere. Need to post more.
Garuru- Their comments on cyber’s roleclaim look town because I also thought it was weird that everybody was upset with cyber for claiming. I mean, how could he have hid his power, it’s pretty obvious? And the rest of their posts seem pretty towny as well.
Cyber- Most of his early posts centered around his doublevoting, so not much there, although his power is most likely town. I would like to know more about why he changed his mind about 2create, tough. So mostly towny for him.
FelixSparks, seastorm, mathgirl- You guys need to post more. Stop lurking.
Kiven- Seems neutral with a very slight townread. He said a lot of the things a lot of other people were saying about 2create, but it didn’t feel like sheeping. And he gave some reads, but I feel he could do more, maybe post more.
Myw- scummy scum, although they might be 3rd party or just have a special role. They were lurking all of D1 and then they spend most of D2 trying to get 2create to roleclaim for no reason other than because he’s gonna die anyway. Which means myw probably doesn’t think 2create is scum because otherwise they wouldn’t care whether or not 2create dies. My guess is either:
1. myw is scumbuddies with 2create and doesn’t want them to die, and so is trying to make it seem like they are against 2create and make 2create roleclaim.
2. same as above, except with masons (less likely).
3. myw suspects 2create is a certain role and wants to see if their guess is true because they need that role for something.
Either way, myw doesn’t look good.
Gnauga- Seems pretty neutral, he focused on 2create being catwagon scum, which is plausible, and cyber trying to get everyone on redwagon, which is slightly less plausible.
2create- At first I thought they were derpscum because of the catwagon vote, but then they seemed more like derptown because they were doing everything town told them to do and offered themselves as a lynch, not to mention the whole myw roleclaim debacle. They could still be scumbuddies with myw, though.
Pilot- Pilot looks kinda scummy imo. First, he kept grannyclaiming, which wasn’t very useful. Next, he said he was fine with catlynch, but didn’t like how Mirdini wasn’t saying anything else except catlynch, which gave off some bad vibes, but not too bad of vibes. Then he said he was gonna look at me/credit/pw, but he hasn’t done that yet. So slight scumlean.
Red- They seem pretty town and have posted a lot, been petty active. They could easily be scum pretending to be town (especially with all the “EVEN Q HAS POSTED MORE THAN YOU GUYS” posts), but I doubt it.
Pala- Pala looks pretty scummy this game as well. He didn’t seem very helpful in the beginning and his support of myw and 2create didn’t look very good either, especially since he later changed his mind about 2create seemingly out of nowhere. Explanations please.
PW- He seems like derptown imo. The redvote didn’t seem very suspicious to me and I thought his wagon looked pretty scummy and came out of nowhere so I defended him. Then he gave some good opinions on yd12k and why he was voting myw. And finally he sealed the deal with not realizing that Dini didn’t have to unvote before voting again. This could all be an act, though.
ICGranola- Pretty neutral about Credit. Partially meta because I know he likes to play meta like a clown, so I don’t question the sillier stuff he does. Also, him pointing out cyber as doublevoter didn’t really seem that bad to me because it would’ve been pretty obvious anyway. Not so sure about granola yet.