RE: Tropefia - A PYP - D2: Milk Stains (21/24)
05-31-2013, 03:50 AM
Two things I forgot to respond to/didn't notice. First is serious, second is a bit of a joke.
In all honesty though I hate massclaims day 1/2/3 as much as anyone but there are very few situations in which someone about to face their lynch (as in, they will get lynched in a few hours if they don't claim) shouldn't claim. I mean either people find out their role in a couple hours when they are lynched or they live another night, maybe two.
I'd rather have a decent outed power role sticking around for one extra night to action away/be killbait and give us the chance to lynch someone else who could be scum, as opposed to just dying right away because they were cop/vig/some other semi-provable role and we lynched them because they felt bad claiming. Sure scum gets to know who they are but this isn't an open setup and scum having to waste a night offing a power role who was about to be lynched while town gets a second shot at killing/a power role living for one more night? Sounds protown to me.
This all being said - I'd rather 2create not claim unless for some reason people refuse to even consider the superior calibornio/PW/youdon't/Kiven lynches and pile on to him instead.
(05-31-2013, 02:46 AM)Red709 Wrote: »what scum would let him liveScum who fears some sort of backup role (because hey bodyguard ain't that strong a protective role) or a watcher/tracker?
(05-31-2013, 02:46 AM)Red709 Wrote: »I don't want pants dropped every lynch thx, but I can't stop them eitherBut Red you have the fastest lost pants in the west :P.
In all honesty though I hate massclaims day 1/2/3 as much as anyone but there are very few situations in which someone about to face their lynch (as in, they will get lynched in a few hours if they don't claim) shouldn't claim. I mean either people find out their role in a couple hours when they are lynched or they live another night, maybe two.
I'd rather have a decent outed power role sticking around for one extra night to action away/be killbait and give us the chance to lynch someone else who could be scum, as opposed to just dying right away because they were cop/vig/some other semi-provable role and we lynched them because they felt bad claiming. Sure scum gets to know who they are but this isn't an open setup and scum having to waste a night offing a power role who was about to be lynched while town gets a second shot at killing/a power role living for one more night? Sounds protown to me.
This all being said - I'd rather 2create not claim unless for some reason people refuse to even consider the superior calibornio/PW/youdon't/Kiven lynches and pile on to him instead.