Tropefia - A PYP - N5: Downed Guy (11/24) (need replacement)

Okay, so 2create confuses me. At first, his mannerisms, such as going "Hey, I don't want to be lynched!", could be a very scummy thing, yes, but I have seen lots of newbtown do this, mainly because they really don't want to be lynched so early in their first game. So, I had 2create pinned as newbtown, and I must admit that wagon does not look so good. But then this happened:

I assumed the first kill was the mafia kill, but ok.

It just seems really weird that he went ahead and assumed frigid was the mafia kill without any indication, when he himself said that it seems like a weird scum kill here:

It is off indeed. Why would scum kill frigidScholar?

(post clipped, refer to full post for context please)

I think that he is scum, and is perfectly aware that the mafia chose to kill frigid and tried to cover up for it by going "man thats a weird thing for scum to do, i do not follow that reasoning therefore i am not scum". Except he derped and revealed that he knew who mafia killed.

So yeah I'm feeling scum on him. Still do not like the way people jumped on him for the basic newbtown thing, I mean holy wow. I'm going to Deadline Vote: 2create.