Re: The Grand Battle [Round 3! Killville!]
09-12-2009, 02:03 PM
Originally posted on MSPA by Draykon.
Show Content
SpoilerI would prefer a post count over a direct poll, simply because that leaves more room for constructive criticism. If someone has to post to get an opinion out, they're more likely to actually explain why, instead of just "I don't like X."
That being said, I'll agree that we've gotten to the point that you can't really say anyone's been doing 'badly.' The whole story's getting really interesting, and I think everyone's contributed alot to that.
My thoughts on individual writers (In no particular order):
Dragon Fogel - Has done a much better job with Eximo Pulvis than I really thought would be possible. Has generally been able to control other characters very well, and kept the plot interesting.
Aryogaton - Early on had a tendancy to not really 'do' much, but has recently gotten a fair bit better. Aeon could potentially be a very interesting character, but I think he still needs to get more involved.
Dexexe - Still has a few readability issues with his writing (No grammatical errors, but still kinda 'off.' Probably to be expected really. It's still much better English than I hear from most foreigners, and many Americans) But in spite of this has been able to keep the story very interesting. Lutherion is also my favorite character, and I'd hate to see him die now.
OddGuy - Like Aryogaton, had a bit of an issue with 'doing things' towards the beginning, but has gotten much better. I really want to see where this whole 'demonic possession' thing goes before I say much more. o.o
Pawn2D4 - Has kept Emily an interesting character, but also has a few readability issues- though this has also improved a fair bit.
Really, if I had to pick someone- and I really don't want to- I'd say Pawn2D4 is my choice. It's not that he's really done 'bad,' it's largely just because Emily feels like she's been sinking into the background a bit this round.
Also, thanks for the compliments guys. [img]images/smilies/icon_heartbeat.gif[/img] I really would post more, it's just half the time I'm not really sure what to post about. x.x
That being said, I'll agree that we've gotten to the point that you can't really say anyone's been doing 'badly.' The whole story's getting really interesting, and I think everyone's contributed alot to that.
My thoughts on individual writers (In no particular order):
Dragon Fogel - Has done a much better job with Eximo Pulvis than I really thought would be possible. Has generally been able to control other characters very well, and kept the plot interesting.
Aryogaton - Early on had a tendancy to not really 'do' much, but has recently gotten a fair bit better. Aeon could potentially be a very interesting character, but I think he still needs to get more involved.
Dexexe - Still has a few readability issues with his writing (No grammatical errors, but still kinda 'off.' Probably to be expected really. It's still much better English than I hear from most foreigners, and many Americans) But in spite of this has been able to keep the story very interesting. Lutherion is also my favorite character, and I'd hate to see him die now.
OddGuy - Like Aryogaton, had a bit of an issue with 'doing things' towards the beginning, but has gotten much better. I really want to see where this whole 'demonic possession' thing goes before I say much more. o.o
Pawn2D4 - Has kept Emily an interesting character, but also has a few readability issues- though this has also improved a fair bit.
Really, if I had to pick someone- and I really don't want to- I'd say Pawn2D4 is my choice. It's not that he's really done 'bad,' it's largely just because Emily feels like she's been sinking into the background a bit this round.
Also, thanks for the compliments guys. [img]images/smilies/icon_heartbeat.gif[/img] I really would post more, it's just half the time I'm not really sure what to post about. x.x