RE: -=- Crooks Hollow III Mafia -=- Day Two: Back to the Tables (21/21)
05-03-2013, 04:45 AM
Okay, sorry for only posting about 5 people yesterday, but I went out to dinner and when I got home, I felt it would be better if I just finished the other analyses in one fell swoop, which wasn’t going to happen yesterday.
Mirdini- He’s been really active and has done a lot of posts that have helped town, so he’s pretty high town on my list. He also asked good questions and defended his posts, just generally making himself stand out on this thread as a kind of leader (at least imo). And his post of his current suspicions had some things I agreed with, although I think Tea’s actually scum and credit’s actually town, so some of his suspicions seem off, but he has pretty good evidence for them.
Cat- Wow, you look really scummy, just voting on Mathgirl and then not really posting other than that just kinda makes you seem suspicious.
Seedy- Similar situation to cat except you seem less scummy since you actually provided a reason for not posting (I can sympathize, going through and analyzing mafia threads with over 5 pages is HARD) and for speedlynching Mathgirl. Still slightly scummy, though.
GenetiBlooded- Similar situation to above, but he also had some good advice about suivig, which seems pretty relevant now with the whole Kane situation, so he has a slight town lean. And Coldblooded hasn’t really posted yet, so not much info.
anacreon- anac seems like the only one who’s really a true neutral to me just because I can’t figure out what their goal is. They haven’t posted much and only a few of the posts were really useful, but the arguments just seemed kind of normal reactions to things, like cat being scum because of the not posting thing. And I’m still not too sure about the pala/anac/pilot group, but they’re probably town so anac’s slightly townish although mostly neutral.
Fragowump- Lurker, not much else to say.
Yewchung- They seem kinda towny with their arguments in https://eagle-time.org/showthread.php?ti...8086 these https://eagle-time.org/showthread.php?ti...8191 posts, but the Sea/Tea alliance has a really weak argument and seems to be based on a really small detail that doesn’t really indicate anything. It basically seems like they’re trying to accuse someone else to throw attention off themselves and that seems kinda scummy. Also, the Granolaman trying to stall end of RVS argument doesn’t really hold up imo because he had a vote that wasn’t random pretty quickly after the whole RVS scandal. Either that or Derptown since they made some really weird mistakes, like accidentally voting Mathgirl instead of Kane.
Jac me- Town (although I’m biased) because most of their posts had some useful info in them even if they didn’t post a lot.
Pilot- Most of the useful material he posts about is in https://eagle-time.org/showthread.php?ti... this post and I don’t really think most of his arguments on Yewchung’s post have much evidence except against the Tea/Sea partnership and the Granolaman RVS stalling. Kane seemed like he was trying to stall an exit to RVS because he voted Mathgirl for trying to stop it and it seemed random at first, so it could be suspected that he didn’t want RVS to end, but it’s also weird because his vote stopped the RVS eventually. And Cat does seem suspicious, although maybe that’s how she is every game. Tea had been posting a lot, but most of it was just “Pala, you’re scum” and wasn’t really useful. Also, the whole mechanics thing made him suspicious, but I don’t think he’s scum because that lynch bandwagon was really poorly put together and lifted suspicion off of pilot. And he also seems town with the pala/anac/pilot group. So town for final view.
Boogeyman- He seems pretty town and a lot of his https://eagle-time.org/showthread.php?ti... arguments are things I agree with, such as pilot’s lynch being terrible, mathgirl being town, and granolaman being not town. And he brought up some good evidence for his votes so he’s pretty towny.
Fuzzy Credit- Fuzzy didn’t really post anything useful and Credit posted some ramblings that were hard to look through, but he doesn’t look like scum since this seems like his normal playing style.
Tea- Wow, Tea, you look really scummy imo. The Mathgirl infolynch seemed okay, but then he brought up Pilot because he didn’t post much even though there were a bunch of other people who hadn’t posted much and he completely ignored them. Then he got into the silly fight with Pala, which was distracting and not helping, and with the evidence that Pala is most likely town, Tea looks really suspicious. And https://eagle-time.org/showthread.php?ti...s argument that Anacreon couldn’t be town because that would mean the people who are lynching Anacreon aren’t scum is just what??? Although his Mirdini vote had good evidence even if it was taken back. Still seems like scum.
Beruru- Lurker
Vortor- Lurker with some posts recently, but they aren’t very useful.
Garuru- They seemed suspicious at first with the ethically wrong statement, but they provided good evidence for that statement later on, so it kinda cancels out. Then there were some posts with slightly good evidence, but not really that much. The pilot vote seemed weird, but it was explained later as a speedlynch, so that’s understandable. And the Kane lynch made sense, so Garuru seems slightly towny to me.
Granolaman- Yeah, I’m almost positive that he’s from a 3rd party and would be totally up for Kane’s suivig roleshoot idea.
Speaking of which, Kane seems to be town now with his role reveal.
And since Granola's probably gonna be killed by Kane, I'll go ahead and Vote: Tea.
Mirdini- He’s been really active and has done a lot of posts that have helped town, so he’s pretty high town on my list. He also asked good questions and defended his posts, just generally making himself stand out on this thread as a kind of leader (at least imo). And his post of his current suspicions had some things I agreed with, although I think Tea’s actually scum and credit’s actually town, so some of his suspicions seem off, but he has pretty good evidence for them.
Cat- Wow, you look really scummy, just voting on Mathgirl and then not really posting other than that just kinda makes you seem suspicious.
Seedy- Similar situation to cat except you seem less scummy since you actually provided a reason for not posting (I can sympathize, going through and analyzing mafia threads with over 5 pages is HARD) and for speedlynching Mathgirl. Still slightly scummy, though.
GenetiBlooded- Similar situation to above, but he also had some good advice about suivig, which seems pretty relevant now with the whole Kane situation, so he has a slight town lean. And Coldblooded hasn’t really posted yet, so not much info.
anacreon- anac seems like the only one who’s really a true neutral to me just because I can’t figure out what their goal is. They haven’t posted much and only a few of the posts were really useful, but the arguments just seemed kind of normal reactions to things, like cat being scum because of the not posting thing. And I’m still not too sure about the pala/anac/pilot group, but they’re probably town so anac’s slightly townish although mostly neutral.
Fragowump- Lurker, not much else to say.
Yewchung- They seem kinda towny with their arguments in https://eagle-time.org/showthread.php?ti...8086 these https://eagle-time.org/showthread.php?ti...8191 posts, but the Sea/Tea alliance has a really weak argument and seems to be based on a really small detail that doesn’t really indicate anything. It basically seems like they’re trying to accuse someone else to throw attention off themselves and that seems kinda scummy. Also, the Granolaman trying to stall end of RVS argument doesn’t really hold up imo because he had a vote that wasn’t random pretty quickly after the whole RVS scandal. Either that or Derptown since they made some really weird mistakes, like accidentally voting Mathgirl instead of Kane.
Jac me- Town (although I’m biased) because most of their posts had some useful info in them even if they didn’t post a lot.
Pilot- Most of the useful material he posts about is in https://eagle-time.org/showthread.php?ti... this post and I don’t really think most of his arguments on Yewchung’s post have much evidence except against the Tea/Sea partnership and the Granolaman RVS stalling. Kane seemed like he was trying to stall an exit to RVS because he voted Mathgirl for trying to stop it and it seemed random at first, so it could be suspected that he didn’t want RVS to end, but it’s also weird because his vote stopped the RVS eventually. And Cat does seem suspicious, although maybe that’s how she is every game. Tea had been posting a lot, but most of it was just “Pala, you’re scum” and wasn’t really useful. Also, the whole mechanics thing made him suspicious, but I don’t think he’s scum because that lynch bandwagon was really poorly put together and lifted suspicion off of pilot. And he also seems town with the pala/anac/pilot group. So town for final view.
Boogeyman- He seems pretty town and a lot of his https://eagle-time.org/showthread.php?ti... arguments are things I agree with, such as pilot’s lynch being terrible, mathgirl being town, and granolaman being not town. And he brought up some good evidence for his votes so he’s pretty towny.
Fuzzy Credit- Fuzzy didn’t really post anything useful and Credit posted some ramblings that were hard to look through, but he doesn’t look like scum since this seems like his normal playing style.
Tea- Wow, Tea, you look really scummy imo. The Mathgirl infolynch seemed okay, but then he brought up Pilot because he didn’t post much even though there were a bunch of other people who hadn’t posted much and he completely ignored them. Then he got into the silly fight with Pala, which was distracting and not helping, and with the evidence that Pala is most likely town, Tea looks really suspicious. And https://eagle-time.org/showthread.php?ti...s argument that Anacreon couldn’t be town because that would mean the people who are lynching Anacreon aren’t scum is just what??? Although his Mirdini vote had good evidence even if it was taken back. Still seems like scum.
Beruru- Lurker
Vortor- Lurker with some posts recently, but they aren’t very useful.
Garuru- They seemed suspicious at first with the ethically wrong statement, but they provided good evidence for that statement later on, so it kinda cancels out. Then there were some posts with slightly good evidence, but not really that much. The pilot vote seemed weird, but it was explained later as a speedlynch, so that’s understandable. And the Kane lynch made sense, so Garuru seems slightly towny to me.
Granolaman- Yeah, I’m almost positive that he’s from a 3rd party and would be totally up for Kane’s suivig roleshoot idea.
Speaking of which, Kane seems to be town now with his role reveal.
And since Granola's probably gonna be killed by Kane, I'll go ahead and Vote: Tea.