RE: -=- Crooks Hollow III Mafia -=- Day One: Wine Cellar (21/21)
04-22-2013, 06:13 PM
(04-22-2013, 04:20 PM)Palamedes Wrote: »On anacreon, I actually kind of liked his last post except for his vote at the end - vote analysis is a strange thing to be doing D1. I think I might be feeling better about him because seastorm's right - his lynch kind of has come out of nowhere and some of the votes against him have been wonky as hell. Most obviously Boogey's where he votes anacreon for the lurker lynch (that isn't a lurker lynch) and for 'being waffly on Tea/Pala' despite him pretty much saying the exact same thing everyone else has been saying about us but adding in a 'watch them just be bussing scum' joke.
That "joke" to me feels like he's trying to float a theory he's not confident enough in to actually put forward with all of his weight behind it. I know he is not the only one to say that "They're both town, but Tea kinda convinced me Pala might be scum in some worlds." But that doesn't mean I like it coming out of anyone else any better. It's a weak, hedging, waffley statement, a chorus doesn't change that fact.
This FP thing is totally a lurker lynch. There has only been one post from that player and that was a long time ago gamestate wise. His votal analysis was not votal analysis. He brings up two groups to look at and then just completely throws out more than half the candidates because he "doesn't know what to think". It's not any kind of analysis if you throw out half the data for no reason. It's even worse when you consider that he has to throw out the half with Cat, the player player that he's got the worst read on. So he's left with a group that includes himself, a nearly universal town read, FP, and someone who's wagon he would probably catch hell for jumping on at this point. That FP vote is terrible.
As for this lynch coming out of nowhere, where were you expecting this to come from? Anacreon wasn't doing anything, so no one was talking about him. Anacreon posted some stuff, and then people voted for him for that stuff. These posts aren't separated by vast gulfs of stuff in between. The causal relationship is pretty obvious. I, at least, was happy (for the most part) with most people posting in this game. Anacreon made me unhappy and so I voted for him.
Anyway. I'll address Kane's question and talk about my thoughts on Pilot after lunch.