RE: WHO ARE THE REAL MONSTERS?!?!?!?!? MAFIA T2 D6: keep your hands inside the ride
04-21-2013, 08:03 AM
(04-21-2013, 07:02 AM)konec0 Wrote: »just for the record, what you're suggesting is this:
#1: Cat and myw are scum. Cat shot you, not Ix. The bullets supposedly bounced off your hide and hit cD.
#2: Pala shot Ix. There's an unaccounted for scumdoc, who doc'd Ix.
My personal opinion is:
i) argument from flavour really
ii) I would like to take this opportunity to remind everyone there's an unaccounted for scum!blocker. To have an unaccounted scumblocker and scumdoc, while not impossible, is pretty darn improbable. Almost all the roles out in the open have some sort of corroboration; we're running out of slots where those could go.
iii) The scum players chose to doc Ix, who has been the least present all game. Rather than, say, Cat, or their mystery 3rd player. Why?
I'm suggesting cat shot ??? (probably not ix if they're scumpals, guessing one of you/seedy/solaris) and got redirected onto me by seedy, and the kill then bounced off me and hit seedy
ii. well if cat/myw are mafia and not masons they can both have unaccounted-for roles so that just makes even more sense? myw has claimed a totally non-provable role, cat's claim is identical to just being vanilla scum doing the kill?
iii. because ix magic-bagged and then quit the game, that's a pretty weird slot and one that isn't an unlikely kill target imo
am arguing from flavor because god if it's not the only thing that makes sense in this game
cat you still haven't answered why myw and you only got masoned last night when neither of you did anything to get masoned with each other last night???
and I think you're smart enough to set up a vig alibi for late-game, yes
especially if you suspected there was a redirector running around who could possibly prove you were a killing role?