Re: Mafia: The Last Resort [D3: Colourblind]
10-15-2011, 07:06 PM
Oh my god wheat, what?!
Let's take this one by one.
You're claiming a flavorcop, with results on 1) a person you got tempmasoned with, who has had ample time between your fishtales to tell you about his flavor himself, and who is currently dead and unable to confirm anything you might have on him, and 2) on Malky, with all you got being a ring of keys. You didn't claim jack other than that so why are you so dead certain keys means mafia? Is there anything at all in your report last night that excludes Malky from being townsided? That said though, I'm actually pretty sure the mafia not having a roleblocker is a point against you, Malky. In a setup with all these cops and doctors, and no vanillas around at all so far I'd think a roleblocker to be standard fare. But then again, a lot of roles don't get informed of being roleblocked, or might just not have any ability to use at all.
And then we're right back on Solaris.
Your top banana in this pile of quotes is still riding the wave of Solaris being such apparent scum and knowledgeable of the mafia roles that he is giving away this knowledge day one and making it such an obvious hook that anyone can pick up on it. If the mafia would collab to make this excuse work on the very first day possible no less I really don't see why they wouldn't talk about it more overnight. Why would Drake need Solaris to tell him to claim blocked, if clearly they had the whole night to conspire over their actions? It makes no sense for mafia to hint at it overday! You're just not considering Solaris to be ACTUALLY TOWN, and genuinely asking if someone got blocked! Blockers happen often, and any info is good info for town! Asking if anyone has anything to report from the night is NOT IN ANY CASE setting some partner up to claim! It's just asking if something happened!
Your next quote is basically digging so deep into the flavor that you're gonna hit the lithosphere sometime soon. I am pretty sure you can tell that there's a key on the other side of a door if you look through the keyhole and don't see anything, say. And even so the flavor tends to be omniscient in tense and style. My night actions when I was being hunted had something about hiding in every corner in unfounded fear of bumping into the hunter. So whoosh! tells me it's unfounded, something my character also shouldn't know about! Wow, I must not be the hunted then! Such points are obviously trivial at best, and if you're genuinely trying to make Drake's roleblocked claim seem less plausible through whoosh' flavor describing how he got blocked, then I'm afraid you'll have to bring a bigger gun.
Your next two quotes I don't see why you've quoted them. Obviously they're talking about a roleblock, maybe because someone brought up being roleblocked. They talk about it, want to know more and speculate a bit about last night's results. How does that make them mafia?
It's reeeeeeeally not suspicious at all in a setup with no vanillas to go around expecting multiple roleblocks.
I'm not sure I follow on your quotes on me either. I claimed just to rig the duel and get a halfwin, and pretty much nothing else. I already discussed some of it with the Hunter that night, and we were both gonna claim regardless. And again, expecting the other side of a hunter/hunted to claim is nothing more than a normal reaction from either side of town or mafia.
All of your arguments seem to be riding on Solaris and co being mafia and picking suspicious posts from there on. You're basically scourging for suspicious posts to the point that you're just quoting Sruixan without saying anything and just having it count.
Let's take this one by one.
You're claiming a flavorcop, with results on 1) a person you got tempmasoned with, who has had ample time between your fishtales to tell you about his flavor himself, and who is currently dead and unable to confirm anything you might have on him, and 2) on Malky, with all you got being a ring of keys. You didn't claim jack other than that so why are you so dead certain keys means mafia? Is there anything at all in your report last night that excludes Malky from being townsided? That said though, I'm actually pretty sure the mafia not having a roleblocker is a point against you, Malky. In a setup with all these cops and doctors, and no vanillas around at all so far I'd think a roleblocker to be standard fare. But then again, a lot of roles don't get informed of being roleblocked, or might just not have any ability to use at all.
And then we're right back on Solaris.
Your top banana in this pile of quotes is still riding the wave of Solaris being such apparent scum and knowledgeable of the mafia roles that he is giving away this knowledge day one and making it such an obvious hook that anyone can pick up on it. If the mafia would collab to make this excuse work on the very first day possible no less I really don't see why they wouldn't talk about it more overnight. Why would Drake need Solaris to tell him to claim blocked, if clearly they had the whole night to conspire over their actions? It makes no sense for mafia to hint at it overday! You're just not considering Solaris to be ACTUALLY TOWN, and genuinely asking if someone got blocked! Blockers happen often, and any info is good info for town! Asking if anyone has anything to report from the night is NOT IN ANY CASE setting some partner up to claim! It's just asking if something happened!
Your next quote is basically digging so deep into the flavor that you're gonna hit the lithosphere sometime soon. I am pretty sure you can tell that there's a key on the other side of a door if you look through the keyhole and don't see anything, say. And even so the flavor tends to be omniscient in tense and style. My night actions when I was being hunted had something about hiding in every corner in unfounded fear of bumping into the hunter. So whoosh! tells me it's unfounded, something my character also shouldn't know about! Wow, I must not be the hunted then! Such points are obviously trivial at best, and if you're genuinely trying to make Drake's roleblocked claim seem less plausible through whoosh' flavor describing how he got blocked, then I'm afraid you'll have to bring a bigger gun.
Your next two quotes I don't see why you've quoted them. Obviously they're talking about a roleblock, maybe because someone brought up being roleblocked. They talk about it, want to know more and speculate a bit about last night's results. How does that make them mafia?
It's reeeeeeeally not suspicious at all in a setup with no vanillas to go around expecting multiple roleblocks.
I'm not sure I follow on your quotes on me either. I claimed just to rig the duel and get a halfwin, and pretty much nothing else. I already discussed some of it with the Hunter that night, and we were both gonna claim regardless. And again, expecting the other side of a hunter/hunted to claim is nothing more than a normal reaction from either side of town or mafia.
All of your arguments seem to be riding on Solaris and co being mafia and picking suspicious posts from there on. You're basically scourging for suspicious posts to the point that you're just quoting Sruixan without saying anything and just having it count.
quidquid Latine dictum sit altum videtur.