Re: Mafia: The Last Resort [D3: Colourblind]
10-15-2011, 01:04 AM
Wwwell... I honestly don't know what to think now. The more Wojjan talked, the more sure I was she was something screwy, but now it's starting to look like she might have just known about Solaris and was trying to save him because he was a powerful power-role. Were they lovered/masoned/whatever like Ix and Wheat claimed? Am I conflating games again?
On the other hand, it's probably more important to look at MalkyTop, Mirdini, Wheat, and Solaris right now. Unless anyone wants to counterclaim VISIONARY, then there doesn't seem to be a whole lot of reason to doubt that Solaris is the one who was talking in nightchat last night. That doesn't even close to mean he necessarily is what he says, of course, but at least we know something now.
I'm having a hard time figuring either of Wheat or Solaris as scum at the moment; there's almost never a good reason for scum fakeclaiming cop and leading a lynch on the town. It's usually a one for one trade, and that's almost never good for the mafia, numerically. The most likely scenario, in my mind, is that one of our claimed inforoles has sanity issues; less likely but still not unlikely is simply that two of our sane inforoles decided to claim on the same day. It's possible that one of them doesn't have the town's best interests at heart, but I can't figure out why they'd set events into motion that would likely end with their lynch when their "guilty" turned up innocent.
For me at the moment, it seems like the decision is between trusting Solaris and trusting Wheat. I think that as it stands right now, I'll side with Wheat first: it seems like if there are any players in cahoots, it's Wojjan and Solaris, which means that if one of our claimers is scum, I'd bet Solaris. Wait, I had a thought... Given that this is a whoosh! game, and we've already seen an odd role or two, it's possible that the scum have some kind of day-illusionist that causes one lynch to flip the way they tell whoosh! to have it flip. That seems... borderline-bastardy, but it would certainly explain why the scumteam would fakeclaim and damned if I can think of any other reasons. I'm not saying this is a likely scenario, but it is a possible one maybe; given that Whooshlaris looks slightly worse than Wheat and I was able to come up with some reason the scum might make themselves such targets, I'm willing to vote with Wheat. Which I already said, but I had that idea midparagraph.
vote: MalkyTop
Fakedit: that's not necessarily the case, Solaris; Wheat specifically didn't tell us what kind of inforole he is, just that he has damning evidence against MalkyTop. It's still possible, as I mentioned above, that Wheat's a sane tracker/watcher/SKcop/whatever and you're just a sane cop.
On the other hand, it's probably more important to look at MalkyTop, Mirdini, Wheat, and Solaris right now. Unless anyone wants to counterclaim VISIONARY, then there doesn't seem to be a whole lot of reason to doubt that Solaris is the one who was talking in nightchat last night. That doesn't even close to mean he necessarily is what he says, of course, but at least we know something now.
I'm having a hard time figuring either of Wheat or Solaris as scum at the moment; there's almost never a good reason for scum fakeclaiming cop and leading a lynch on the town. It's usually a one for one trade, and that's almost never good for the mafia, numerically. The most likely scenario, in my mind, is that one of our claimed inforoles has sanity issues; less likely but still not unlikely is simply that two of our sane inforoles decided to claim on the same day. It's possible that one of them doesn't have the town's best interests at heart, but I can't figure out why they'd set events into motion that would likely end with their lynch when their "guilty" turned up innocent.
For me at the moment, it seems like the decision is between trusting Solaris and trusting Wheat. I think that as it stands right now, I'll side with Wheat first: it seems like if there are any players in cahoots, it's Wojjan and Solaris, which means that if one of our claimers is scum, I'd bet Solaris. Wait, I had a thought... Given that this is a whoosh! game, and we've already seen an odd role or two, it's possible that the scum have some kind of day-illusionist that causes one lynch to flip the way they tell whoosh! to have it flip. That seems... borderline-bastardy, but it would certainly explain why the scumteam would fakeclaim and damned if I can think of any other reasons. I'm not saying this is a likely scenario, but it is a possible one maybe; given that Whooshlaris looks slightly worse than Wheat and I was able to come up with some reason the scum might make themselves such targets, I'm willing to vote with Wheat. Which I already said, but I had that idea midparagraph.
vote: MalkyTop
Fakedit: that's not necessarily the case, Solaris; Wheat specifically didn't tell us what kind of inforole he is, just that he has damning evidence against MalkyTop. It's still possible, as I mentioned above, that Wheat's a sane tracker/watcher/SKcop/whatever and you're just a sane cop.