Re: Mafia: The Last Resort [D3: Colourblind]
10-10-2011, 06:13 PM
Yep, I'm all I claimed in nightchat and I still have my resutl of Times and g0m being linked "in a way".
Of course that's so ridiculously vague it could mean anything, and I'd certainly not treat it as any form of guilty unless one of them flips scum (in which case some rigorous investigating would hafta happen).
Solaris you said you'd suspect Times if PYP's flipped scum:
You still stand by that or?
Fogel/everyone in general, you should watch out about the messagemasoning if only because I'm getting flashbacks to my modfia role (though that one was town) where I could listen in on tempmasonchats I created, that'd be a pretty nasty scumrole but I could see it being a thing :I
Pinary you did explain your presumed reasons for being on every townlynch so far in the Star, and honestly I just don't find it very satisfactory!
Your reasons for voting g0m still feel weak. Perhaps he has a vote-related power, perhaps he has some other reason, but generally people don't want to go claiming powers on d1 and voting them for being mysterious isn't particularly helpful when you just leave it at "vote: person for being mysterious" (as you did, since you didn't pressure g0m for the rest of the day).
The line of "others apparently thought the same" is rubbing me the wrong way for obvious reasons (a weak justification for being on his lynch, when you had stated reasons as to why you were on the lynch when you voted him that would presumably take precedence).
You were also mentioning Wojj and Pharms as scummy throughout D2, and now that they've been proven 3P I find that to be a wonderful distraction opportunity scum wouldn't pass up on (as I mentioned in my last post of the day yesterday).
Finally you never acknowledged PYP's response to your post voting him yesterday, despite having a day and a half to do so (you did post between his post and whoosh's dayend) which feels like you were going "oh I'll just let the lynch happen no need to post more stuff in response that I might slip with".
IN CONCLUSION I guess you feel scummy.
Would like to hear what you think of D2 now, though I also find it a pretty weird scumhunting method to base your late-in-the-day votes on the previous day's events :I
After all that wall I'd want to vote you if it weren't for (Vote:) TimeothyHour who uh is sticking out like a sore thumb on the Tea lynch if Fogel's presumably town, not to mention the PYP lynch (as is MrGuy on both, actually. If neither Times nor Guy're scum I'll be pretty baffled).
Of course that's so ridiculously vague it could mean anything, and I'd certainly not treat it as any form of guilty unless one of them flips scum (in which case some rigorous investigating would hafta happen).
Solaris you said you'd suspect Times if PYP's flipped scum:
Solaris Wrote:If Pyps is mafia, then Sruixian is likely town.
If he's town, then I would think that Times is deserving of suspicions.
You still stand by that or?
Fogel/everyone in general, you should watch out about the messagemasoning if only because I'm getting flashbacks to my modfia role (though that one was town) where I could listen in on tempmasonchats I created, that'd be a pretty nasty scumrole but I could see it being a thing :I
Pinary you did explain your presumed reasons for being on every townlynch so far in the Star, and honestly I just don't find it very satisfactory!
Pinary Wrote:((response to D2 aggro by me))
g0m had done nothing but be mysterious with his "I can't tell you things at this time" votes, and I saw absolutely zero effort from him to be useful. You, on the other hand, had at least been making an effort to do things. Tea? He was part of a bigass back-and-forth that just went over my head. I'm not a mafia expert- the only impressions I got from the Tea-debate was that it was a load of nitpicking and sniping that set off no scum-alerts for me from either side.
((Pyp lynch accusation from me))
I was away camping. When I got back, I read over the thread, compiled some thoughts, and posted them. Pipe seemed scummy by the time I'd read to the end of D1, and others apparently thought the same. Yes, I was late to the wagon. It was either vote for someone I thought was scum or just sit by because other people were already voting for him, and I felt that maybe doing my part to help put some scum in the ground was the way to go. I'll probably do something similar tomorrow- read over D2 in one go, see what pops out at me, and drop my vote accordingly.
Your reasons for voting g0m still feel weak. Perhaps he has a vote-related power, perhaps he has some other reason, but generally people don't want to go claiming powers on d1 and voting them for being mysterious isn't particularly helpful when you just leave it at "vote: person for being mysterious" (as you did, since you didn't pressure g0m for the rest of the day).
The line of "others apparently thought the same" is rubbing me the wrong way for obvious reasons (a weak justification for being on his lynch, when you had stated reasons as to why you were on the lynch when you voted him that would presumably take precedence).
You were also mentioning Wojj and Pharms as scummy throughout D2, and now that they've been proven 3P I find that to be a wonderful distraction opportunity scum wouldn't pass up on (as I mentioned in my last post of the day yesterday).
Finally you never acknowledged PYP's response to your post voting him yesterday, despite having a day and a half to do so (you did post between his post and whoosh's dayend) which feels like you were going "oh I'll just let the lynch happen no need to post more stuff in response that I might slip with".
IN CONCLUSION I guess you feel scummy.
Would like to hear what you think of D2 now, though I also find it a pretty weird scumhunting method to base your late-in-the-day votes on the previous day's events :I
After all that wall I'd want to vote you if it weren't for (Vote:) TimeothyHour who uh is sticking out like a sore thumb on the Tea lynch if Fogel's presumably town, not to mention the PYP lynch (as is MrGuy on both, actually. If neither Times nor Guy're scum I'll be pretty baffled).