Mystery Box

Dang this is a pretty hard choice. I think I want to go with the 4th option, keeping open a line for communication.

Also, in more general goal-oriented terms, what if in order to get to this Mystery Master, we tried, well, a civic approach? What I mean is, we had a slight run-in with the law before, but that doesn't mean we have to be a criminal from now on. They didnt get our name or appearance. We could totally try to work within the system in order to find this guy. These Creeps, for example. I imagine that fighting them is a relatively important job, like a firefighter, and our Pawn is likely more equipped to do so than the average citizen. We could take up a job and use our position to gather information about higher-up people who might be the Mystery Master. We'd probably need to keep our duplication power a secret though.
I mean we could also be a criminal, avoiding officers of the law and moving through the city's underground. That has it's own advantages and disadvantages. Just saying there's a choice here, we aren't locked in by our previous actions.