RE: Buzzfia - One Silent Night - Day 1 (22/22 live)
10-11-2018, 04:51 AM
Wheat you brought up that contradiction a while after I said I had super vague goodfeels about amos :V
Also I didn't read it as 'no lynching day one is bad' as much as I had read it 'wasting time throwing a lynch at Wheat is bad', and regardless I usually think it's good when someone risks drawing attention to themselves by disagreeing with the general consensus when there isn't a need to.
I also believe at the time I was trying to think of who, if anyone but literally myself, I would be okay with getting your items when you inevitably died and was stretching for a single person so early in the game.
Sunspider I can't help but reiterate the point that has been brought up countless times: If we lynch anyone who is scum, or honestly even half the people who are town (and probably have more useful roles than Wheat's) they will almost definitely just vote him and survive the day with a ton of items. The lynch target does not die if Wheat has votes. Nobody dies if Wheat has the most votes. There is no way to lynch most folks without Wheat dying and giving all of his stuff to them, some of which will make said lynch target much more difficult to deal with. This is a problem that only gets worse and worse as the game goes on. Sunspider why have you ignored these arguments?
Myeth is your Jon vote to save him or to try and get an item?
People should get off Jon/Wheat so we can keep track of the items when he pops (unless someone can present an argument for why it's better to fill a more random spread).
Also I didn't read it as 'no lynching day one is bad' as much as I had read it 'wasting time throwing a lynch at Wheat is bad', and regardless I usually think it's good when someone risks drawing attention to themselves by disagreeing with the general consensus when there isn't a need to.
I also believe at the time I was trying to think of who, if anyone but literally myself, I would be okay with getting your items when you inevitably died and was stretching for a single person so early in the game.
Sunspider I can't help but reiterate the point that has been brought up countless times: If we lynch anyone who is scum, or honestly even half the people who are town (and probably have more useful roles than Wheat's) they will almost definitely just vote him and survive the day with a ton of items. The lynch target does not die if Wheat has votes. Nobody dies if Wheat has the most votes. There is no way to lynch most folks without Wheat dying and giving all of his stuff to them, some of which will make said lynch target much more difficult to deal with. This is a problem that only gets worse and worse as the game goes on. Sunspider why have you ignored these arguments?
Myeth is your Jon vote to save him or to try and get an item?
People should get off Jon/Wheat so we can keep track of the items when he pops (unless someone can present an argument for why it's better to fill a more random spread).