RE: The Wander Island Incident - Day Four: LOST & FOUND ELECTION BONANZA [14/21]
09-25-2018, 02:12 PM
Well, glad to get a response there at least. I'm having mixed reactions on the content, but let's go here.
I'm still really curious to see this game's setup in the postgame. Because we have so far had...
a confirmed 3p with a kill (LegendaryQ)
a player with a day kill that killed scum (Granolaman)
a night kill who killed scum (the “soul drain” night 1 that hit pharmacy and we assume was “the siren”)
a night kill who attacked scum (airey losing bulletproof, which solaris claimed).
That's a lot of death from players who aren't on the main scum team (barring shenanigans). And every kill that DID go off hit scum.
It's kinda funny that we've killed 2 of the (presumed 4, maybe 5?) scum despite missing them with the lynch itself 3 times. It's part of why that amnesiac turned scum theory keeps sticking with me, because things can't REALLY be going that well. And if there IS a serial killer, then apparently they haven't gotten a successful kill since night 1 (unless solaris is bluffing, but that would be a hell of a risk for solaris)
I'll be honest, I wasn't super sold on the NTA vote, though their reaction at the end of the day did them no favors in my book. I only held off because I was hoping that if they had the time for the angry outburst post they might have time to answer a few of my questions, but we can't always get what we wanted.
Beru would pick me and slorange as town over solaris and lordly, the semi-clears? Interesting. Granted, we only have their word on their claims, but Solaris' claim in particular is hard to argue with when there's no counterclaim for an attack that must have happened and hit scum.
I distinctly did NOT receive a boot, for what it's worth.
I'm actually kinda not thrilled that people started cancelling votes for Beru and voting for Schazer before beru even spoke up? Like, Beru's being at softlynch was gone before their arrival to answer some questions? I guess since they did show up and answer some things it worked out, but eh. The fact that we have multiple people who still haven't posted today (slorange, RL) and schazer who was incredibly superficial and disappeared is worrying. I never want to trust the idea of scum giving up and rolling over. But if all of the semi-clears are in fact town, we don't exactly have a lot of possibilities left.
But um. Schazer. Yeah. I guess this is happening today. So if you're available to answer some questions as well, I wouldn't mind getting a few things on record from you, at the very least.
1) You've been kinda distant in the game, not really posting much or analyzing things, and staying out of major discussions for most of the game. Many of your comments are like the one to start off today, completely superficial. Why?
2) You've and SleepingOrange have both claimed that the other are town. Are you able or willing to explain or elaborate on this? Do you have any other information to share?
3) On day 2, you voted for acionyx (in my slot) with basically no reason given, and prodded others (including those he was arguing with) to do so as well. Is there a reason you wanted this player slot dead, and if so, can you explain it now? Do you still want me dead?
4) IIRC SleepingOrange claimed that you were town, but also said that if one of the two of you were to be lynched they'd prefer it be you. Do you feel the same? If one of you and sleepingOrange had to be lynched today, which would you pick?
5) What are your strongest town and scum reads at this point?
6) Do you think that LegendaryQ was the game's only third party? What do you suspect are the numbers at this point for the scum team and any surviving 3Ps?
7) tehPilot seems to have some people thinking they're a top scum candidate and others thinking they're a top town candidate. What's your opinion?
8) Same as beruru. You must name 5 living town players (not including yourself) and you win right now. Who are your picks, and why? Is there anyone that most people would pick that you definitely wouldn't?
9) Are there any actions or unexplained occurrences that you in particular want answers to?
10) Who do you think we should lynch today? Who would you like to pressure and get information from rather than lynch outright if we had more time?
I'm still really curious to see this game's setup in the postgame. Because we have so far had...
a confirmed 3p with a kill (LegendaryQ)
a player with a day kill that killed scum (Granolaman)
a night kill who killed scum (the “soul drain” night 1 that hit pharmacy and we assume was “the siren”)
a night kill who attacked scum (airey losing bulletproof, which solaris claimed).
That's a lot of death from players who aren't on the main scum team (barring shenanigans). And every kill that DID go off hit scum.
It's kinda funny that we've killed 2 of the (presumed 4, maybe 5?) scum despite missing them with the lynch itself 3 times. It's part of why that amnesiac turned scum theory keeps sticking with me, because things can't REALLY be going that well. And if there IS a serial killer, then apparently they haven't gotten a successful kill since night 1 (unless solaris is bluffing, but that would be a hell of a risk for solaris)
I'll be honest, I wasn't super sold on the NTA vote, though their reaction at the end of the day did them no favors in my book. I only held off because I was hoping that if they had the time for the angry outburst post they might have time to answer a few of my questions, but we can't always get what we wanted.
Beru would pick me and slorange as town over solaris and lordly, the semi-clears? Interesting. Granted, we only have their word on their claims, but Solaris' claim in particular is hard to argue with when there's no counterclaim for an attack that must have happened and hit scum.
I distinctly did NOT receive a boot, for what it's worth.
I'm actually kinda not thrilled that people started cancelling votes for Beru and voting for Schazer before beru even spoke up? Like, Beru's being at softlynch was gone before their arrival to answer some questions? I guess since they did show up and answer some things it worked out, but eh. The fact that we have multiple people who still haven't posted today (slorange, RL) and schazer who was incredibly superficial and disappeared is worrying. I never want to trust the idea of scum giving up and rolling over. But if all of the semi-clears are in fact town, we don't exactly have a lot of possibilities left.
But um. Schazer. Yeah. I guess this is happening today. So if you're available to answer some questions as well, I wouldn't mind getting a few things on record from you, at the very least.
1) You've been kinda distant in the game, not really posting much or analyzing things, and staying out of major discussions for most of the game. Many of your comments are like the one to start off today, completely superficial. Why?
2) You've and SleepingOrange have both claimed that the other are town. Are you able or willing to explain or elaborate on this? Do you have any other information to share?
3) On day 2, you voted for acionyx (in my slot) with basically no reason given, and prodded others (including those he was arguing with) to do so as well. Is there a reason you wanted this player slot dead, and if so, can you explain it now? Do you still want me dead?
4) IIRC SleepingOrange claimed that you were town, but also said that if one of the two of you were to be lynched they'd prefer it be you. Do you feel the same? If one of you and sleepingOrange had to be lynched today, which would you pick?
5) What are your strongest town and scum reads at this point?
6) Do you think that LegendaryQ was the game's only third party? What do you suspect are the numbers at this point for the scum team and any surviving 3Ps?
7) tehPilot seems to have some people thinking they're a top scum candidate and others thinking they're a top town candidate. What's your opinion?
8) Same as beruru. You must name 5 living town players (not including yourself) and you win right now. Who are your picks, and why? Is there anyone that most people would pick that you definitely wouldn't?
9) Are there any actions or unexplained occurrences that you in particular want answers to?
10) Who do you think we should lynch today? Who would you like to pressure and get information from rather than lynch outright if we had more time?