Forum Overhaul Fix-'em-up Jamboree

I've followed the steps you mentioned, but am unable to reproduce any bug with thread subscriptions. Are you both sure you selected the notification type you wanted, and confirmed it? And are you sure it's not just further down the list of your subscribed pages? (It sorts them by how recent they have been updated, I believe).

If so and you still have this issue, please lemme know what browser and OS you're running.