RE: The Wander Island Incident - Day Three: A Bloody Denouement [16/21]
09-13-2018, 02:45 AM
While I'm flipping back through things, I want to bring up a thought I had driving back today: we have two claimed vigilante roles, a purported serial killer (/vig in some people's analyses?), and a vengeful townie all on the table. What's the level of death in this setup? I'm thinking on a similar train of thought when we were talking about the presence of vengeful roles in the setup. We've now the evidence countering a lot of those old suspicions - and perhaps we're in a similar situation with these roles. This is why I'm super interested to hear what Lordly has to say - having some extra perspective from that slot after it went from active to quiet would be nice.
I feel a little bit better about Palamedes on post content; not sure how I feel about vote placement/trends though.
@Slorange: you are correct in all your reasons why I would suspect you! The biggest thing you have going for yourself, in my view, is you've got content on this day and I wouldn't consider your later stuff to be continuing a tunnel on Granola. I also don't mind your reads even if I don't super agree with every one of them / they're largely agreeable overall. I also don't know exactly how to feel about you and Schazer being coaligned town when Schazer's been pinging me as off all game, but if the reality is that compelling and not worthy of reveal yet I can hold off for another day.
What about NTA's flip will tell you about x1372's and Sai's alignment? I could be convinced to move to NTA; would rather wait until Schazer says something else in the wake of Airey's death.
@RL: in post #681, you state you aren't opposed to a vote on Granola; there is also a note at the end of the post that states a lack of confidence. #719 you cast the vote as wanting to push it in the direction you support, although your post before that isn't super confident as well. Now that we have solid belief Granola is more likely town than scum, is there any vote you feel confident in?
@NTA: you mentioned in post #674 that you did not agree with the consensus town read on Slorange, and you voted for Schazer - have you come to a more developed opinion on Slorange, and how the two of them supporting each other as town plays into that?
@Coldblooded: do you think Numbers or Pala as scum is more likely? I don't really think Seedy is scum personally, and you said one of those three might be scum. My initial feeling is Numbers might be more likely scum, but I could see Pala based on position on votes maybe.
@Lordly: what made you feel Granola was scum leading up to him delivering the daykill? Any thoughts on NTA, Slorange, Sai perchance?
@Sai: who would you want to lynch instead of Schazer?
I feel a little bit better about Palamedes on post content; not sure how I feel about vote placement/trends though.
@Slorange: you are correct in all your reasons why I would suspect you! The biggest thing you have going for yourself, in my view, is you've got content on this day and I wouldn't consider your later stuff to be continuing a tunnel on Granola. I also don't mind your reads even if I don't super agree with every one of them / they're largely agreeable overall. I also don't know exactly how to feel about you and Schazer being coaligned town when Schazer's been pinging me as off all game, but if the reality is that compelling and not worthy of reveal yet I can hold off for another day.
What about NTA's flip will tell you about x1372's and Sai's alignment? I could be convinced to move to NTA; would rather wait until Schazer says something else in the wake of Airey's death.
@RL: in post #681, you state you aren't opposed to a vote on Granola; there is also a note at the end of the post that states a lack of confidence. #719 you cast the vote as wanting to push it in the direction you support, although your post before that isn't super confident as well. Now that we have solid belief Granola is more likely town than scum, is there any vote you feel confident in?
@NTA: you mentioned in post #674 that you did not agree with the consensus town read on Slorange, and you voted for Schazer - have you come to a more developed opinion on Slorange, and how the two of them supporting each other as town plays into that?
@Coldblooded: do you think Numbers or Pala as scum is more likely? I don't really think Seedy is scum personally, and you said one of those three might be scum. My initial feeling is Numbers might be more likely scum, but I could see Pala based on position on votes maybe.
@Lordly: what made you feel Granola was scum leading up to him delivering the daykill? Any thoughts on NTA, Slorange, Sai perchance?
@Sai: who would you want to lynch instead of Schazer?
![[Image: c48AoKl.png?1]](https://i.imgur.com/c48AoKl.png?1)