The Wander Island Incident - Night Four - Five For One [13/21]

Granolaman: I can genuinely come up with a mechanically and socially plausible world in which granola is a mafia aligned day killer and bus murdered Airey since he was definitely going to die already and granola had  come up several times through several players' suspicions and he was probably going to be watched Pretty closely next. I really want that to be the world we're living in, because granola really was my current strongest scum suspicion, for pretty meager reasons, but that just seems so astronomically unlikely compared to the much more reasonable option of granola is a standard day killer and my suspicions were completely unfounded that I pretty much have to assume town for now. I'm not going to go so far as a couple of other people and call him confirmed, but if this is a scum gambit it's as masterful as it is stupid.

You echo my feelings on Granolaman pretty perfectly here. He was Actually my Strongest Scumread until just now, and It's  only because I think it'd be a Dumb Play to do as he did if he WERE Scum that that feeling has gone Sideways into confused. It could just be a Doumblebluff

With Reference to Me Being Quiet, I have Been, Mainly because my first instinct is to Hush Up and let the Professionals Work, In Case I Make a Noob Mistake. Which Is, in itself, a noob mistake, I Know.