RE: The Wander Island Incident - Day Three: A Bloody Denouement [16/21]
09-12-2018, 04:34 PM
(09-12-2018, 03:08 PM)Palamedes Wrote: »@Pilot: What are your thoughts on me?
Mentally I've had you in the lurker read (null) bin. You haven't posted too much (which I can forgive for the reasons you've just now laid out) and there isn't much in the way of meaningful interaction from other players to put any of your posts into context for me. I have been rereading and catching up but haven't been in a spot to write a super long post. Been phone playing since this day began.
Your later posts today definitely pick up the prior slack I felt but I'll see how things fare when I get to the full analysis. But that aside, quick thing or two --
(Should be good for tonight and forward to desktop post again. See you all with that in seven-ish hours?)
-- Some of your points against me I'm not seeing - where have I poked x1372 (the only other person to have a vote on me)? I would not consider my reply to their post a poke, nor do I even think anything concretely suspicious of that slot. x1372 is playing very town and their predecessor I had a good read on, so not sure where you're drawing that from.
And in case it wasn't clear in #648 and now that we have additional alignment forms to work with:
Definitive Town: Jacquerel, CB, Granola
Town: Solaris, x1372, Seedy
Light Town: Lordly
Up for review: Slorange, Pala, Laser
Scumreads (from super slight to bad): Beruru, Numbers, NTA, Schazer
I'm comfortable putting beru at the very top of light scumread because the Granola tunneling just looks bad in hindsight. Obviously subject to change. Laser is in review as well since I only noted the early daystart's pressure on them and now we have more to look at. Also want to check the low volume posters against prior reads now that Airey is dead scum.
--
I'm favoring Granola as a town dayvig over the possible scum gambit world. Don't want to entertain that topic for much longer today since I think it's a distraction against pursuing a second lynch.
The point raised that it is not a definite clear is correct, but I feel strongly one way about it. I also thought Granola was town with a bad voting record earlier in the day so yeah. Fits my view of the gamestate better.