RE: The Wander Island Incident - Day Three: A Bloody Denouement [16/21]
09-12-2018, 03:08 PM
What an incredible time to come back to the thread.
Honestly I've been in a bit of a personal rut so I'm still really far behind but two vigs makes me wary enough but look how wrong I was about that in nostalgfia (over and over again) so I'm going to chalk it up to the serial killer probably being a serial killer (like, a useful one but still).
I'm going to also not talk about a lot of the Airey stuff because there was very clearly a votal gimmick and he's dead anyways. Obvious stuff is the earlier people going after him look really good (Jaq, x1372, Solaris notably), other, later pressure felt a little more tacked on.
I feel pretty alright with seedy despite (I say, hypocritically) the lack of posts and reads today, their exchange with Jaq about revealing info didn't seem like the kind of thing scum would throw around - at least, not without pressuring Numbers.
Speaking of Numbers they and NTA feel kind of tacked on to the already tacked on Slorange/beru scumteam Airey threw out. Like, previous posts and interactions with Numbers makes me think this is the anti-bussing person to follow now that Airey is scum but if Numbers flips town I'd want to give the other two a good look. NTA maybe because less concrete opinions were put on them but for now that feels like Airey just trying to come up with another random pick.
Not a massive fan of Sai putting Laser fourth(?) on their scum list for just 'not being useful'. Opinions given by Sai on Airey and Schazer (other scum reads) seem way more damning than that but apparently at best they're all considered equal lynches.
I don't like Lordlyhour' random capitalization. Mark as s. suspicious. More seriously, want to see the promised more from them besides just piling on Airey.
@NTA: I believe Slorange is town because Schazer said they were town, and Schazer is town because Slorange said they were town. I kind of really want to lynch one of them because unless this is ballsy as hell scum play or they're lovers my bet on their play would be scum tricking town. That said, I don't know for sure which is the better lynch and I don't like picking things like that at random. Schazer probably based solely on reads and interactions, but that's easy to say because they're posting way more.
Back and forth and concerns about some Coldblooded ploy read as very natural, plus there was the intense grilling of the dead that I don't think most scum would bother to do. Add x as a moderate town read I guess?
TehPilot is like, right that nobody is really talking about me (besides Sai, who only really did it because readwall and also because I called them out previously), but at the same time I find it interesting that while promising reads and opinions the only thing Pilot's been doing besides responding to questions is throwing out weak probes like this at the two people currently voting him.
I don't like Laser's reaction to Airey's votalfucking but it did seem very genuine. Schazer's on the other hand I didn't like in any way.
Since apparently it isn't always clear in these long posts:
No point in reads, town: Coldblooded, Jaq, granola, Solaris
Town: x, Laser
Pretty town: seedy, LordlyHour
Eh: beruru, Slorange
Do not like: Sai, NTA
Kill: Numbers, Schazer, TehPilot
Question time!
@Sai: Like I said I've really let this drop from my priorities, and I agree that Coldblooded is super town, but I'm not sure if I understand how Pharmacy's flip practically cleared them. Could you elaborate? I'm also curious about the Pharmacy/Numbers interaction you mentioned because I don't remember much there (though I'll try and make a quick skim later tonight).
@x: Thoughts on there being a town sided vig that hit Pharmacy and someone else, given how we now have one confirmed vig and a fairly likely second vig?
@Pilot: What are your thoughts on me?
@Numbers: What are your thoughts on me, beruru, Schazer, and Pilot?
@LordlyHour: There were two scum on the Airey wagon before his death. Who were they and why?
@Laser: What thoughts were you formulating before Airey messed things up?
Honestly I've been in a bit of a personal rut so I'm still really far behind but two vigs makes me wary enough but look how wrong I was about that in nostalgfia (over and over again) so I'm going to chalk it up to the serial killer probably being a serial killer (like, a useful one but still).
I'm going to also not talk about a lot of the Airey stuff because there was very clearly a votal gimmick and he's dead anyways. Obvious stuff is the earlier people going after him look really good (Jaq, x1372, Solaris notably), other, later pressure felt a little more tacked on.
I feel pretty alright with seedy despite (I say, hypocritically) the lack of posts and reads today, their exchange with Jaq about revealing info didn't seem like the kind of thing scum would throw around - at least, not without pressuring Numbers.
Speaking of Numbers they and NTA feel kind of tacked on to the already tacked on Slorange/beru scumteam Airey threw out. Like, previous posts and interactions with Numbers makes me think this is the anti-bussing person to follow now that Airey is scum but if Numbers flips town I'd want to give the other two a good look. NTA maybe because less concrete opinions were put on them but for now that feels like Airey just trying to come up with another random pick.
Not a massive fan of Sai putting Laser fourth(?) on their scum list for just 'not being useful'. Opinions given by Sai on Airey and Schazer (other scum reads) seem way more damning than that but apparently at best they're all considered equal lynches.
I don't like Lordlyhour' random capitalization. Mark as s. suspicious. More seriously, want to see the promised more from them besides just piling on Airey.
@NTA: I believe Slorange is town because Schazer said they were town, and Schazer is town because Slorange said they were town. I kind of really want to lynch one of them because unless this is ballsy as hell scum play or they're lovers my bet on their play would be scum tricking town. That said, I don't know for sure which is the better lynch and I don't like picking things like that at random. Schazer probably based solely on reads and interactions, but that's easy to say because they're posting way more.
Back and forth and concerns about some Coldblooded ploy read as very natural, plus there was the intense grilling of the dead that I don't think most scum would bother to do. Add x as a moderate town read I guess?
TehPilot is like, right that nobody is really talking about me (besides Sai, who only really did it because readwall and also because I called them out previously), but at the same time I find it interesting that while promising reads and opinions the only thing Pilot's been doing besides responding to questions is throwing out weak probes like this at the two people currently voting him.
I don't like Laser's reaction to Airey's votalfucking but it did seem very genuine. Schazer's on the other hand I didn't like in any way.
Since apparently it isn't always clear in these long posts:
No point in reads, town: Coldblooded, Jaq, granola, Solaris
Town: x, Laser
Pretty town: seedy, LordlyHour
Eh: beruru, Slorange
Do not like: Sai, NTA
Kill: Numbers, Schazer, TehPilot
Question time!
@Sai: Like I said I've really let this drop from my priorities, and I agree that Coldblooded is super town, but I'm not sure if I understand how Pharmacy's flip practically cleared them. Could you elaborate? I'm also curious about the Pharmacy/Numbers interaction you mentioned because I don't remember much there (though I'll try and make a quick skim later tonight).
@x: Thoughts on there being a town sided vig that hit Pharmacy and someone else, given how we now have one confirmed vig and a fairly likely second vig?
@Pilot: What are your thoughts on me?
@Numbers: What are your thoughts on me, beruru, Schazer, and Pilot?
@LordlyHour: There were two scum on the Airey wagon before his death. Who were they and why?
@Laser: What thoughts were you formulating before Airey messed things up?