RE: The Wander Island Incident - Day Three: A Bloody Mystery [17/21]
09-10-2018, 03:37 PM
@TehPilot You know what, I'm going to go ahead and apologize for being a bit too nasty there. I definitely went overboard. Yeah, I was frustrated when someone made a vote toward ending the day early right after I'd gotten through 3ish hours of catch-up and started asking questions, and I still see it as a potential scum move, but I shouldn't have been so mean about it. Sorry.
Your hint wasn't close to massclaim divulgence... yet. But it came at a point where there was no reason for it, theoretically puts heat off you, probably tells scum more than it tells town, and makes any sort of trueclaiming by the rest of town more dangerous if we do edge toward mass claim territory. It wasn't a big thing in isolation, but the timing and lack of concrete information for town to consider are both problematic from my perspective. You are correct that the revelations/claims about last night are technically more potentially damaging, but they also come with concrete information for town to consider as we move forward with our lynch today. Side note, I personally wouldn't have made the claim Acio did in my spot, but I understand why he did it and what he was trying to do.
Interesting reads, even if they don't completely gel with my own. You actually feel worse about Solaris after today's interactions? Also, with regard to Blazer/Lordly, did their claim and offer to be lynched d2 make you lean more or less town on them? Finally, is it just their claims today that make you feel good about Jacquerel and Coldblooded, or is there something else to it?
@Airey
Look, you've said a lot of things today. Things that don't mesh with what others are saying in a way that makes you look bad. You also seemed to be focusing way more on a serial killer answer than seems prudent, though you ARE claiming you got shot at by what you think is a SK. And finally, you just made a claim that, if true, seems INCREDIBLY anti-town to have revealed publicly. Since you're already at soft lynch, I'm sure you wouldn't mind answering a few questions .
1) Given that they seem to contradict you, do you now believe that one or both of coldblooded and jacquerel are scum? If just one, which and why?
2) If you DID get shot by a serial killer before... whatever blood thing occurred, why are you claiming it?
3) You just claimed bomb. If it's true and everyone believed it, scum will no longer target you. This completely defeats the purpose of your role itself. Why make that claim, instead of just announcing that you were targeted?
4) Would you like to take a second stab at a role claim? If so, what were you hoping to gain out of the bomb claim?
5) What two players do you believe most likely to be coaligned scum?
6) You are voting for Solaris on assumption of being a Serial Killer. I stated earlier that I very strongly disagree with hunting for a SK at this juncture. Do you disagree with my logic on that? If so, please explain why I'm wrong.
7) You're suspicious of Solaris. Suppose they're part of the scum team, not a serial killer. Who's the rest of their team?
8) What two players would you like to hear most from about their current reads?
Your hint wasn't close to massclaim divulgence... yet. But it came at a point where there was no reason for it, theoretically puts heat off you, probably tells scum more than it tells town, and makes any sort of trueclaiming by the rest of town more dangerous if we do edge toward mass claim territory. It wasn't a big thing in isolation, but the timing and lack of concrete information for town to consider are both problematic from my perspective. You are correct that the revelations/claims about last night are technically more potentially damaging, but they also come with concrete information for town to consider as we move forward with our lynch today. Side note, I personally wouldn't have made the claim Acio did in my spot, but I understand why he did it and what he was trying to do.
Interesting reads, even if they don't completely gel with my own. You actually feel worse about Solaris after today's interactions? Also, with regard to Blazer/Lordly, did their claim and offer to be lynched d2 make you lean more or less town on them? Finally, is it just their claims today that make you feel good about Jacquerel and Coldblooded, or is there something else to it?
@Airey
Look, you've said a lot of things today. Things that don't mesh with what others are saying in a way that makes you look bad. You also seemed to be focusing way more on a serial killer answer than seems prudent, though you ARE claiming you got shot at by what you think is a SK. And finally, you just made a claim that, if true, seems INCREDIBLY anti-town to have revealed publicly. Since you're already at soft lynch, I'm sure you wouldn't mind answering a few questions .
1) Given that they seem to contradict you, do you now believe that one or both of coldblooded and jacquerel are scum? If just one, which and why?
2) If you DID get shot by a serial killer before... whatever blood thing occurred, why are you claiming it?
3) You just claimed bomb. If it's true and everyone believed it, scum will no longer target you. This completely defeats the purpose of your role itself. Why make that claim, instead of just announcing that you were targeted?
4) Would you like to take a second stab at a role claim? If so, what were you hoping to gain out of the bomb claim?
5) What two players do you believe most likely to be coaligned scum?
6) You are voting for Solaris on assumption of being a Serial Killer. I stated earlier that I very strongly disagree with hunting for a SK at this juncture. Do you disagree with my logic on that? If so, please explain why I'm wrong.
7) You're suspicious of Solaris. Suppose they're part of the scum team, not a serial killer. Who's the rest of their team?
8) What two players would you like to hear most from about their current reads?