RE: The Wander Island Incident - Day Three: A Bloody Mystery [17/21]
09-09-2018, 11:17 PM
(09-09-2018, 10:43 PM)Granolaman Wrote: »(09-08-2018, 01:59 PM)x1372 Wrote: »Granolaman - our recently townfirmed Day 2 lynch (who you voted for) considered you the most likely to be scum of the people voting for the day 1 lynch (also not a scum faction lynch). Please explain what makes him wrong about this, and rank the following players in order of scumminess: TehPilot, BlazerC, Jacquerel, Solaris, Coldblooded, seedy, Palamedes, Robust Laser
He's arguably not wrong. From a votal analysis perspective I look horrible. If he thought I was actually scum though he sure as hell didn't confront me about it. That was half the reason I wanted him dead: he made all these gestures at people who might be scum but didn't follow up on anything. Even now that I know he's town his reads still look like crowd-pleasing filler rather than anything analytical.
From your list:
Town [CB, Jacq, Sol]
Town* [seedy, Pala]
Lite-town [BlazerC]
Null [TehPilot]
Scum? [Robust Laser]
*I suspect these two are town but they live in my perpetual blindspot
RL's doing an AtE here and while I don't think anyone here would fake one it certainly doesn't win any town points with me.
Airey was definitely the SK shot and the SK continues to be a-OK in my book. Keep doing the lord's work and smite the lurkers fish-friend!
Actually @Airey how did you survive getting shot? You aren't another walrus are you? Also if you think Solaris is the SK why are you voting for them instead of one of your scum reads?
Vote: Airey
Well i wasn't supposed to live and neither was the SK but i am guessing because someone or something did something with blood my bait to kill SK has now failed so that is all out the window.
Plan and simple i want SK dead over scum because i know they can win with scum so the difference between then is moot and just an extra death per night which is not helping town at all.
~no longer a bartender but still helping drunks