The Wander Island Incident - Night Four - Five For One [13/21]

I’m definitely not going to think ac is town on the presumption that they have a death power and the further presumption that death power = town.

I think this is a miscommunication situation. I think your parsing of this statement is technically correct but I think the redundant nature of the sentence indicates it's mistyped. I think she meant to say that she disagrees with both the presumption that AC has a death power and the presumption that death power=town and therefore doesn't agree with the conclusion that AC is mechanically town. She continues to restate these points throughout her subsequent posts.

The only incidence of the sentiment you're talking about other than the one you pointed out earlier is here which appears to be responding to the post where I explain why I think she's scum

Show Content

Spoiler

I also don’t think that “ac has an on-death thing” is truly necessary to explain their behavior nor do I think it explains the way they’ve played perfectly
it would make some of it (mostly the resignation towards death) make more sense but I don’t understand why you find it so totally convincing

I am not saying it’s a GOOD role. again I hate bringing up meta especially when mirdini is powerless to watch as I analyze his modding meta but if I recall correctly scum in quarantine DID have a quack doctor (that was only revealed when flipped)

there are reasons to put a role in that aren’t “this is good for this faction” such as:
-obfuscating “town roles” and “scum roles”
-iterating on a theme
-giving someone A Role makes them feel more special and involved
-Fun

also I did say that I think ac’s behavior has other explanations (and that I think it’s also weird that you’re so certain about them based on play that is vaguely suggestive at best), I’m just focusing on the mechanical part because it’s what boggles me the most about your interpretation

and I’ve never had a “hard reason” to believe schazer is scum, what

To be frank I think you're too intent on peacekeeping here and reading too much into that first line; I think her argument (prior to mechanics discussion) about why to think AC is scum is insubstantial but that's subjective and we're never going to get anywhere on it

I don't think the two instances where it's brought back up have enough meat to them to indicate it's a strong thing she's considering compared to actually formulating a response to the mechanics argument and /not/ a response that answers the question I give

This isn't rhetorical btw name me something that fits the description, what can you give scum that is actually /worth/ them dying. Something that is worth scum dying when there is a serial killer in play to make them die faster