The Wander Island Incident - Night Four - Five For One [13/21]

Blease explain how this makes me a jester?

because your reasoning is contradicting itself and it's garbage

And Q is also un-aligned with town?

You're missing the point.

Mafia are informed of their scumbuddies at the start of the game and nothing more. Third Party or Town, as far as Mafia knew, they were aware that Legendary Q was "not-mafia" and that's the important part, because Mafia would be happy with a lynch that wasn't targeted at someone they knew wasn't on their team.

So as far as bandwagons and information goes, the flip was effectively the same as townie lynch. (And vice-versa, for whatever reason. Again: "Un-aligned with Mafia" is the important part.)

I do agree that I'm slightly glad that the Third-Party got out of the way for the reasons you listed, but that's not what I'm arguing against you for.

Show Content

SpoilerMinor humor note: I do find it amusing that what is probably one of the most complex and intricately designed roles in a srs-mafia game was killed by lynch immediately out of the gate. I totally imagine dini was annoyed at that.

@BlazerC, on D1 you suggested Pharms and Sai might be aligned (#202 - #204). I know we don't have anything yet from today to go off of, and, honestly? Sai didn't give us a lot to work with on D1. However, now that Pharms' flipped Scum: do you stand by that assertion? Is Sai plausibly Scum?

Already talked about this in post #294:

But also Pharm was scum! Which at first, reminds me of something I pointed out earlier...

{quote snip}

Pharm coming to Sai's defence using flavour text as their argument was weak as I said, which somewhat paints the action in a strange light. Was Pharm defending a fellow scum, or where they defending (as Sai pointed out) someone who they knew was a townie to make themselves look as good possible? Given how Sai acted yesterday, I'm inclined to believe they were just trying to defend a townie and were pressuring themselves to say stuff. But still, something to consider.

I'm not sure but they feel townie, in other words. Based on Pharm's lurky attitude, my immediate read is that they pressured themselves to say something and came to Sai's defense because it's easy for scum to defend a townie because they know who the non-mafia players are.

It plays into my hunch of Numbers, who Pharm was arguing against when they were defending Sai. I think Numbers is still just... in the "new player who isn't reading into the right posts" camp. Which in turn inclines me to lean towards a town Sai.

However, this could drastically change in the future. So: I would really like to know Sai's current opinion on the recent developments, if they're here.

And:

Anyone else got questions for me? I tend to work better with a framework to build from.

Slam me with your opinion on Seedy, NTA. I'm curious.