The Wander Island Incident - Night Four - Five For One [13/21]

My read of that line is “by virtue of not being dead this person has become more suspicious”.
If they continue not to contribute but continue to be alive then it implies there’s a reason mafia aren’t taking a “free” kill which won’t teach us anything, that reason being that they know that person is coaligned.
Its not criticism of the scum team but a note of something to think about in three days time. It’s weak reasoning in day two but I think it is worth keeping in mind for the future.