RE: The Wander Island Incident - Day One: Incident Report
08-23-2018, 06:57 PM
I forgot how overwhelming this shit is if you don't like, post in the game, I will try and be more on top of what is going on tomorrow, at the very least so that I can be interrogated, especially because I'm about to vote for Q so that someone dies today when there's only an hour of the day left.
I've been struggling to have any reads on anyone at all to be frank but that should be normal on day one and is a bad reason to not have posted anything.
If it helps my current reading of people who have been mentioned is:
I feel good about Sai and Coldblooded.
Acio I should feel good about but because he has a reputation and posts a lot I find it harder to trust him because, of those things. Which is stupid but there we are.
Reyweld's early identification of scum tactics seemed shaky to me and I would say "they're new" but my meta knowledge is that they did pretty passably in the last game so I'm less convinced that I would.
Numbers looks like someone who doesnt know how mafia works and I have literally no idea what side they are on as a result of that
Posts like "if i could cop anyone it would be myself" are just impossible for me to parse because if you think about it for a second that's obviously not something someone who already knows they are town would want and therefore why would you post that in the thread as either town or mafia
I really don't like NTA and Palamedes raising the spectre of revealing anything at all about their role or flavour day one but that isn't a scum read unless I'm willing to believe that they'd just do it in the hopes that someone else will.
Schazer and Slorange both have no desire to do anything useful on day one and I know factually in my head that this is not constructive or helpful to town but can't bring myself to take that as a scum read
However paradoxically the one person I am finding myself reading as scum who I didn't notice any other discussion of is awkwardCarapace, who while they also seem like a new player has done almost nothing except shitpost and then make posts that to me seemed more like an active attempt to not lynch today, versus schazer and slorange's sort of aggressive apathy towards the concept
Fortunately there's no chance they're going to die today so they have a chance to respond to that
Solaris is clearly scum but her death can wait until tomorrow.
I'm willing to lynch Q for pushing a bandwagon on a lurker as if it was anything other than that, general sort of sidestepping, and also feel worse about them because of numbers' erratic behaviour surrounding them
I don't think it's anything like a guaranteed scum kill but it will give people more stuff to talk about tomorrow compared to if nobody died, including selfishly, a lot of reason to talk to me, which is good reason for me to post more in this thread
Vote Q
I've been struggling to have any reads on anyone at all to be frank but that should be normal on day one and is a bad reason to not have posted anything.
If it helps my current reading of people who have been mentioned is:
I feel good about Sai and Coldblooded.
Acio I should feel good about but because he has a reputation and posts a lot I find it harder to trust him because, of those things. Which is stupid but there we are.
Reyweld's early identification of scum tactics seemed shaky to me and I would say "they're new" but my meta knowledge is that they did pretty passably in the last game so I'm less convinced that I would.
Numbers looks like someone who doesnt know how mafia works and I have literally no idea what side they are on as a result of that
Posts like "if i could cop anyone it would be myself" are just impossible for me to parse because if you think about it for a second that's obviously not something someone who already knows they are town would want and therefore why would you post that in the thread as either town or mafia
I really don't like NTA and Palamedes raising the spectre of revealing anything at all about their role or flavour day one but that isn't a scum read unless I'm willing to believe that they'd just do it in the hopes that someone else will.
Schazer and Slorange both have no desire to do anything useful on day one and I know factually in my head that this is not constructive or helpful to town but can't bring myself to take that as a scum read
However paradoxically the one person I am finding myself reading as scum who I didn't notice any other discussion of is awkwardCarapace, who while they also seem like a new player has done almost nothing except shitpost and then make posts that to me seemed more like an active attempt to not lynch today, versus schazer and slorange's sort of aggressive apathy towards the concept
Fortunately there's no chance they're going to die today so they have a chance to respond to that
Solaris is clearly scum but her death can wait until tomorrow.
I'm willing to lynch Q for pushing a bandwagon on a lurker as if it was anything other than that, general sort of sidestepping, and also feel worse about them because of numbers' erratic behaviour surrounding them
I don't think it's anything like a guaranteed scum kill but it will give people more stuff to talk about tomorrow compared to if nobody died, including selfishly, a lot of reason to talk to me, which is good reason for me to post more in this thread
Vote Q