RE: The Wander Island Incident - Day One: Incident Report
08-23-2018, 06:57 AM
Alright brief comeback. Sorry I'm mostly doing these long posts but I'm pretty busy nowadays.
Even less of a fan of Q for that Sai vote (what about following Acio's vote on Sai was worth going for over literally anyone else at the point you voted?)
Speaking of Sai, at first I feel pretty good about just from a content point of view but a lot of the posts he's come up with since reappearing seem fairly rushed for said content (giant quote walls, post by post response with varying quality of comments and questions). That sort of makes me wary, since at I find scum play is usually about quantity over quality as far as analysis goes. Sai, what do you think of me?
Why are we all assuming a random lynch will give us a bunch of townfirms?
seedy is sort of off for me for the lurker comment (either follow that by trying to get a lurker lynch through or explain why you're proposing it but not being a part of it), as far as I'm concerned lurker lynches are for when you don't have a proper target come end of day, since it's probably one of the only good ways to get rid of them (which yes, can often be necessary) but you're not wasting a day(s) going after them.
Not The Author's response to the public cop question is not great, like maybe they're going for a typing gimmick but it seemed like it was trying to dance around a real answer, and I'm just not a fan of unvoting without pursuing a new lead like they did earlier either.
(For the record, I'd reveal myself since it'd make me a target and I really don't want to live into endgame and blow things again but since that isn't a serious or likely allowed answer I'd pick Granola. Feel pretty neutral on him and there's a chance that he won't get taken out by scum for a while without that confirm unlike Acio.)
Numbers isn't really doing anything to make me want to change my vote. Could move to Q with an off chance of NTA or maybe Sai if that's the way things go.
Even less of a fan of Q for that Sai vote (what about following Acio's vote on Sai was worth going for over literally anyone else at the point you voted?)
Speaking of Sai, at first I feel pretty good about just from a content point of view but a lot of the posts he's come up with since reappearing seem fairly rushed for said content (giant quote walls, post by post response with varying quality of comments and questions). That sort of makes me wary, since at I find scum play is usually about quantity over quality as far as analysis goes. Sai, what do you think of me?
Why are we all assuming a random lynch will give us a bunch of townfirms?
seedy is sort of off for me for the lurker comment (either follow that by trying to get a lurker lynch through or explain why you're proposing it but not being a part of it), as far as I'm concerned lurker lynches are for when you don't have a proper target come end of day, since it's probably one of the only good ways to get rid of them (which yes, can often be necessary) but you're not wasting a day(s) going after them.
Not The Author's response to the public cop question is not great, like maybe they're going for a typing gimmick but it seemed like it was trying to dance around a real answer, and I'm just not a fan of unvoting without pursuing a new lead like they did earlier either.
(For the record, I'd reveal myself since it'd make me a target and I really don't want to live into endgame and blow things again but since that isn't a serious or likely allowed answer I'd pick Granola. Feel pretty neutral on him and there's a chance that he won't get taken out by scum for a while without that confirm unlike Acio.)
Numbers isn't really doing anything to make me want to change my vote. Could move to Q with an off chance of NTA or maybe Sai if that's the way things go.