RE: Nostalgfia Day 5 - Flies like an arrow
07-08-2018, 04:16 AM
Okay so first off sorry for missing out on a bunch of stuff, work is super fun when it goes on forever ;-;.
Anyways, Mirdini I specifically remember you going on a few times about how believable CSJ's claim was - yeah you never really made a hard push away but it was definitely notable how willing you were to give him the benefit of the doubt to go after Robo or n-o. Also confused about how you are confirmed town, unless you mean someone else?
As for getting Coldblooded lynched instead of CSJ, sure I did that, but Wheat covered that pretty well vis-a-vis how it would have made no sense to do that. I'd also add that I don't think a single person was looking at her in any remotely serious way, and in fact was getting less attention than many other low posters. The idea that Coldblooded would have easily been lynched by now and CSJ wasn't going to be dead the immediate next day is ridiculous.
I'll concede I messed up on there being two confirmed town inventors (which makes sense in an item oriented game) but we have far from there being two confirmed town or scum anything past that.
It's also pretty crazy that Mirdini argues that the reasoning for my vote is ridiculous when his seems to equate to:
1. Me not revealing the name of my cop item for a reason that successfully eludes him, especially given how I almost straight up answered him yesterday (by accident but still feels pretty obvious looking back).
2. Coldblooded WINE
Schazer why did you shoot Solaris N1, when your bullets weren't stolen? Also why would you risk getting bullets in the night and killing people who shouldn't be killed? Why not announce your shit immediately if you felt it was just useless obfuscation so that you wouldn't potentially get caught visiting someone and cause aforementioned issues? As for your question, I haven't read too much exasperation from Dini? No more than any other active person at all.
Rolecops abound makes me actually feel better about anti-aligned roles as opposed to matching based on alignment, though that's assuming Reyweld can be believed (not sure why he'd take the risk with so many living players if he wasn't one but that doesn't mean much for alignment).
Mirdini assuming that I'm wrong and you're actually town, is it actually so impossible that Schazer is scum? You say that Wheat is the closest thing to verifiable town but you make more arguments based around Schazer having to be town than much else. Like, Schazer could be town but the world makes more sense and is significantly more straightforward in the opposite world as far as I'm seeing, for reasons both I and Wheat have elaborated on before and during this debacle.
Oh hey note, Mirdini is going on about his roleblocking being confirmed him but we had a confirmed town roleblocker alive at the time with no other claim of blocking so it'd be easy to hop on that and take responsibility days later.
Reyweld actually brings up a good point re: doc control but that almost makes me wonder if Schazer is a third party mason/killer? Doesn't make sense in a scum Mirdini world but works if he's town.
Thoughts on the Laser groupcopping is probably Pharms as most likely town but makes a lot more sense as scum if Mirdini or Laser are town. Reyweld is sort of in the middle, also not fitting with both Mirdini and Laser but could potentially work with them individually.
seedy I don't believe scum is entirely in the inactives and unless scum has two busdrivers plus some other incredible thing I don't see how everyone else can be telling the truth just in sheer terms of balance.
Will concede that I want to hear from the less active people (especially as it comes to results from claimed roles) which coincides with the fact that I'm not done properly going over these past few pages and am about to pass out and start it all again tomorrow. Please let me know if there's any major shit I'm missing still or need to weigh in on and I'll try and finish all of my thoughts up tomorrow.
Anyways, Mirdini I specifically remember you going on a few times about how believable CSJ's claim was - yeah you never really made a hard push away but it was definitely notable how willing you were to give him the benefit of the doubt to go after Robo or n-o. Also confused about how you are confirmed town, unless you mean someone else?
As for getting Coldblooded lynched instead of CSJ, sure I did that, but Wheat covered that pretty well vis-a-vis how it would have made no sense to do that. I'd also add that I don't think a single person was looking at her in any remotely serious way, and in fact was getting less attention than many other low posters. The idea that Coldblooded would have easily been lynched by now and CSJ wasn't going to be dead the immediate next day is ridiculous.
I'll concede I messed up on there being two confirmed town inventors (which makes sense in an item oriented game) but we have far from there being two confirmed town or scum anything past that.
It's also pretty crazy that Mirdini argues that the reasoning for my vote is ridiculous when his seems to equate to:
1. Me not revealing the name of my cop item for a reason that successfully eludes him, especially given how I almost straight up answered him yesterday (by accident but still feels pretty obvious looking back).
2. Coldblooded WINE
Schazer why did you shoot Solaris N1, when your bullets weren't stolen? Also why would you risk getting bullets in the night and killing people who shouldn't be killed? Why not announce your shit immediately if you felt it was just useless obfuscation so that you wouldn't potentially get caught visiting someone and cause aforementioned issues? As for your question, I haven't read too much exasperation from Dini? No more than any other active person at all.
Rolecops abound makes me actually feel better about anti-aligned roles as opposed to matching based on alignment, though that's assuming Reyweld can be believed (not sure why he'd take the risk with so many living players if he wasn't one but that doesn't mean much for alignment).
Mirdini assuming that I'm wrong and you're actually town, is it actually so impossible that Schazer is scum? You say that Wheat is the closest thing to verifiable town but you make more arguments based around Schazer having to be town than much else. Like, Schazer could be town but the world makes more sense and is significantly more straightforward in the opposite world as far as I'm seeing, for reasons both I and Wheat have elaborated on before and during this debacle.
Oh hey note, Mirdini is going on about his roleblocking being confirmed him but we had a confirmed town roleblocker alive at the time with no other claim of blocking so it'd be easy to hop on that and take responsibility days later.
Reyweld actually brings up a good point re: doc control but that almost makes me wonder if Schazer is a third party mason/killer? Doesn't make sense in a scum Mirdini world but works if he's town.
Thoughts on the Laser groupcopping is probably Pharms as most likely town but makes a lot more sense as scum if Mirdini or Laser are town. Reyweld is sort of in the middle, also not fitting with both Mirdini and Laser but could potentially work with them individually.
seedy I don't believe scum is entirely in the inactives and unless scum has two busdrivers plus some other incredible thing I don't see how everyone else can be telling the truth just in sheer terms of balance.
Will concede that I want to hear from the less active people (especially as it comes to results from claimed roles) which coincides with the fact that I'm not done properly going over these past few pages and am about to pass out and start it all again tomorrow. Please let me know if there's any major shit I'm missing still or need to weigh in on and I'll try and finish all of my thoughts up tomorrow.