RE: Nostalgfia Day 3- A very very long time.
06-07-2018, 03:44 PM
Hey, it's mafia!
I've caught up on day three and here are my thoughts:
I don't buy CSJ's jester claim. They only seemed like they were really trying hard to draw a lynch and then making jester claims after people started being suspicious. It doesn't track for me, if they actually wanted to be lynched they would just keep acting normal suspicious. I think CSJ is the way to go for today, but it seems like that's the way things are headed anyway, and I guess it would be rude to push towards hammer after everybody banded together to extend the day? So I'll withhold that vote for now.
We currently have two people claiming investigative roles, as well as there being investigative items out there as we've already seen. This seems like a lot, in terms of balance! I think it's worth keeping an eye on Robust Laser and robottobt; probably one of them is not being on the level. Robust Laser appears to have made some Bad Decisions in the use of their claimed investigative power. I trust seedy, they're playing Miller by the book. If seedy wasn't a Miller, all they'd be doing by claiming it D1 is drawing undue attention to themselves. I'm sympathetic to RL's claim of just having not thought things through, though. I don't see the benefit in falsely claiming what they did. I'm hoping RL makes better use of their role tonight. On the other side, robottobt's claims about what is going on with their power don't really hold together (talking about investigating by year, but then making claims about results on particular players. Talking about day-activation of night abilities, which was explicitly said not to occur by the mods), and their concrete info claim is that wheat and CSJ are co-aligned. Given everything around CSJ, this claim would be a definite black mark against wheat, which has clear benefit as a false claim. So, on the balance, I'd suspect robottobt over Robust Laser.
There's also the matter of nercania-orccelga, who I still have suspicions of for the same reasons as before. To the extent they've posted today, they're just being real cagey; nothing there that makes me feel better about them.
I've caught up on day three and here are my thoughts:
I don't buy CSJ's jester claim. They only seemed like they were really trying hard to draw a lynch and then making jester claims after people started being suspicious. It doesn't track for me, if they actually wanted to be lynched they would just keep acting normal suspicious. I think CSJ is the way to go for today, but it seems like that's the way things are headed anyway, and I guess it would be rude to push towards hammer after everybody banded together to extend the day? So I'll withhold that vote for now.
We currently have two people claiming investigative roles, as well as there being investigative items out there as we've already seen. This seems like a lot, in terms of balance! I think it's worth keeping an eye on Robust Laser and robottobt; probably one of them is not being on the level. Robust Laser appears to have made some Bad Decisions in the use of their claimed investigative power. I trust seedy, they're playing Miller by the book. If seedy wasn't a Miller, all they'd be doing by claiming it D1 is drawing undue attention to themselves. I'm sympathetic to RL's claim of just having not thought things through, though. I don't see the benefit in falsely claiming what they did. I'm hoping RL makes better use of their role tonight. On the other side, robottobt's claims about what is going on with their power don't really hold together (talking about investigating by year, but then making claims about results on particular players. Talking about day-activation of night abilities, which was explicitly said not to occur by the mods), and their concrete info claim is that wheat and CSJ are co-aligned. Given everything around CSJ, this claim would be a definite black mark against wheat, which has clear benefit as a false claim. So, on the balance, I'd suspect robottobt over Robust Laser.
There's also the matter of nercania-orccelga, who I still have suspicions of for the same reasons as before. To the extent they've posted today, they're just being real cagey; nothing there that makes me feel better about them.