Re: Mafia: The Last Resort [D2: Interceptor Intercepted]
09-09-2011, 09:13 PM
Right, an actual post - don't all look so amazed, people!
I have to agree with Mirdini that PyP is looking like a surrendered townie (not the vanilla bit on account of this being a no-vanilla game), if only because giving up is just a silly move irregardless of alignment but it's more likely that a townie would throw in the towel than a mafioso, who would do more damage to their team with their death than a townie. That said, I don't like his obsession with Wojj at all and would have been happy to interpret it as scum testing the waters to see if people would be up for lynching her if it weren't for the vote, placed at a point I would have expected mafia to have long since given up at. Oh heck, I'm conjecturing aren't I? Given my rust that's not exactly a good thing...
But right non-PyP opinions - Whimbrel being a bit scummy as their sole D2 post was a mostly contentless vote on PyP? Some glimmers of town from Malky for trying to contribute despite some bewilderment (may or may not also be due to empathy as I can't help but feel quite confused as well) and I'm quite happy with Wheat since he was willing to stick out a properly justified opinion on PyP relatively early. Beyond that we're starting to get into gut territory which given the lack of attention the thread has had from me probably isn't somewhere to pluck nuggets from, but if asked to name a few more townies I'd probably go for Drak and Ix before most others...
I think I've seen Pines and PL brought up as scummy, so I might take a peek in my next post... it does strike me as interesting that Prof has now brought a vote for vote from seemingly nowhere but that might just be me being blind...
I have to agree with Mirdini that PyP is looking like a surrendered townie (not the vanilla bit on account of this being a no-vanilla game), if only because giving up is just a silly move irregardless of alignment but it's more likely that a townie would throw in the towel than a mafioso, who would do more damage to their team with their death than a townie. That said, I don't like his obsession with Wojj at all and would have been happy to interpret it as scum testing the waters to see if people would be up for lynching her if it weren't for the vote, placed at a point I would have expected mafia to have long since given up at. Oh heck, I'm conjecturing aren't I? Given my rust that's not exactly a good thing...
But right non-PyP opinions - Whimbrel being a bit scummy as their sole D2 post was a mostly contentless vote on PyP? Some glimmers of town from Malky for trying to contribute despite some bewilderment (may or may not also be due to empathy as I can't help but feel quite confused as well) and I'm quite happy with Wheat since he was willing to stick out a properly justified opinion on PyP relatively early. Beyond that we're starting to get into gut territory which given the lack of attention the thread has had from me probably isn't somewhere to pluck nuggets from, but if asked to name a few more townies I'd probably go for Drak and Ix before most others...
I think I've seen Pines and PL brought up as scummy, so I might take a peek in my next post... it does strike me as interesting that Prof has now brought a vote for vote from seemingly nowhere but that might just be me being blind...