RE: Nostalgfia Day 2 - Death comes at some time
05-09-2018, 12:56 AM
(05-08-2018, 09:04 PM)Palamedes Wrote: »Oh right, and I don't like Sunspider's theorycrafting post on the CSJ/granola scumteam framing them because it feels both like hard deflection and an attempt to distance themselves from CSJ.
You're definitely right that I don't like Nola building lynch momentum against me for someone else's questionable behavior. Also, the gambit I mentioned is a common and effective scum tactic. If you're honestly arguing that me making small efforts to keep town from lynching people I know to be town (myself), and that pointing out common scum tactics for the newbies are both scummy behaviors now, I've got to ask you why the heck you think that.
Also, for what it's worth coming from me; if I was on a scumteam with CSJ, I'd have been shouting at them to cut out the buddying as soon as it started. I would not have let it keep going this long, as that's basically suicidal; when a player Role-Flips Scum, looking for the players they've been cozy with is Scum-Hunting 101. I'm not a Mafia master in the slightest, but I'm at least better than that.
(05-09-2018, 12:09 AM)Mirdini Wrote: »love all this probably-town soft-claiming, we can all line up nice and orderly for the mafia to decapitate us
though I guess they might just be OVERWHELMED WITH CHOICES at this point and not entirely sure which ones are real and which ones are not-so-real so SHRUG
This. I am seriously not a fan of all the early soft-claiming and showing-of-hands to the scumteam right now. But what's said is said, and we can work with it.
So, if I understand what people have said about night 1 actions:
- SinkingSailor died, presumably Mafiakilled since no one owned up to vig-killing them.
- Schazer was targeted by Someone, and had whatever they got out of their present stolen from them. No one claimed to have done this so far.
- Granolaman was targeted by Wheat and Cat, but they were redirected to Wheat.
- Pharmacy was targetting Wheat, and was joined by redirected players. They also claimed to get "some kind of joke item" after last night.
- a52 claims to have seen all these players target Wheat.
- Wheat is confused about whether or not their item was stolen for some reason, but corroborated a52's claim (Wheat's dog-emote wording is still confusing to me, so if they or someone else can clarify this, please do).
Rules Clarification Question for RobotNerd: Can a Mafia player nightkill someone and ALSO use an item or power? Can multiple items/powers be used per night?
Anyway, did I miss anything or mess up anything in this run-down of the night actions claimed so far?