Re: Mafia: The Last Resort [D2: Interceptor Intercepted]
09-05-2011, 05:28 AM
So, I've thought things over a bit, looked through the thread, and I have some thoughts.
Woff's roleclaim is kind of suspicious in my eyes. The explanation of some aspects of the role were fumbled, which I admit probably have coloured my thoughts that the roleclaim might be total BS. It just seems to me a really good way to have two mafias cleared as third party, especially considering the roles don't effect anything more than each other. On the other hand, her (his? If I have the pronoun wrong I apologize.) posts haven't been particularity scummy before this, and the claim might very well be legit. Right now I'm going to wait and see who claims to be the hunter before I make a conclusive decision.
I also agree that the way mirdini has been going after pines is odd, if not suspicious, but not enough for me to vote just yet.
Who IS suspicious enough for me to vote for, however, is pickyerpoison. I reread the alleged too-long post that pyps made right before tea was lynched, and my problem with it is not just the length, but also the content of the post.
Pyp's main reasoning for voting tea was that tea was covering for sruix, and that if tea was town he'd seriously reconsider his suspicions about sruix. That argument, in my opinion, comes off as an attempt to clear sruix of suspicion by a fellow mafia. So, right now, I'm going to vote for pyps for the really suspicious post and say sruixian is definitely someone I'm watching for more suspicious activity.
I should also address ix's accusation. I didn't really have a whole lot of opinions day 1 besides randomvoting tea and concluding tea was the scummiest candidate at the time, mainly because we didn't have a whole lot of info. So, I ended up only communicating those opinions. Now that I have more info flying around, I can construct more opinions, and therefore I'm probably going to end up posting and analyzing more, and hopefully be able to construct a fairly accurate big picture.
Anyway, its late, typing on a tablet is terrible, and I don't have anything else to say right now, so I'm going to end this post here.
Woff's roleclaim is kind of suspicious in my eyes. The explanation of some aspects of the role were fumbled, which I admit probably have coloured my thoughts that the roleclaim might be total BS. It just seems to me a really good way to have two mafias cleared as third party, especially considering the roles don't effect anything more than each other. On the other hand, her (his? If I have the pronoun wrong I apologize.) posts haven't been particularity scummy before this, and the claim might very well be legit. Right now I'm going to wait and see who claims to be the hunter before I make a conclusive decision.
I also agree that the way mirdini has been going after pines is odd, if not suspicious, but not enough for me to vote just yet.
Who IS suspicious enough for me to vote for, however, is pickyerpoison. I reread the alleged too-long post that pyps made right before tea was lynched, and my problem with it is not just the length, but also the content of the post.
Pyp's main reasoning for voting tea was that tea was covering for sruix, and that if tea was town he'd seriously reconsider his suspicions about sruix. That argument, in my opinion, comes off as an attempt to clear sruix of suspicion by a fellow mafia. So, right now, I'm going to vote for pyps for the really suspicious post and say sruixian is definitely someone I'm watching for more suspicious activity.
I should also address ix's accusation. I didn't really have a whole lot of opinions day 1 besides randomvoting tea and concluding tea was the scummiest candidate at the time, mainly because we didn't have a whole lot of info. So, I ended up only communicating those opinions. Now that I have more info flying around, I can construct more opinions, and therefore I'm probably going to end up posting and analyzing more, and hopefully be able to construct a fairly accurate big picture.
Anyway, its late, typing on a tablet is terrible, and I don't have anything else to say right now, so I'm going to end this post here.