Re: Mafia: The Last Resort [Day 1: The Beginning]
08-23-2011, 04:20 PM
I'm just gonna say here (cos i thought id said it earlier, but giving the thread a quick once-over, i dont think i have) that i didnt find Sruix's initial post that got people voting him very suspicious, and once people started pointing it out, i went back to have a look at it, and i STILL didnt find it suspicious. I'm not sure what people are seeing in that particular post thats so scummy... i mean, the one thing i seem to pick up on is that he used a lot of words which is...well, i use a lot of words too, regardless of what faction im with. As for his apparent nervousness, i thought (and he's later confirmed) that it was more a case of being out of practice then anything else.
Basically, since a lot of people voted him - some for RVS reasons, some with seamingly stronger reasons - im wondering if i didnt miss something here?
The thing is, putting down the lynch candidates to a binary option - especially in the early days - is often a very scummy thing to do. Its never best to limit your options, but the impression i get from this post is lack of knowledge rather then maliciousness. I have no strong read in this game currently, and i wouldnt really feel comfortable lynching anyone right now. However, Guy, you're becoming my scummiest read in the game - not by much, to be fair, but if i absolutely had to lynch someone today, it would probably be you.
However, before i put my vote anywhere, lets play Question Time. I'd like everyone in the game (including myself, though im gonna let a few others post answers before i do) to answer who they would A) Cop, B) Doc, and C) Vig if they had to do so right now, with reasons. The reasons are more important then the names, so make sure you dont forget em!
Basically, since a lot of people voted him - some for RVS reasons, some with seamingly stronger reasons - im wondering if i didnt miss something here?
MrGuy Wrote:Specifically, what I find made Tea "more suspicious" is that whole thing with the vague hunches. It just seemed desperate to me. At the same time, as I believe has already been mentioned, a day one lynch is advantageous for the town, and since it appears to be between Tea and Sruixan, I simply thought Tea was the scummier candidate.
Sorry :V
The thing is, putting down the lynch candidates to a binary option - especially in the early days - is often a very scummy thing to do. Its never best to limit your options, but the impression i get from this post is lack of knowledge rather then maliciousness. I have no strong read in this game currently, and i wouldnt really feel comfortable lynching anyone right now. However, Guy, you're becoming my scummiest read in the game - not by much, to be fair, but if i absolutely had to lynch someone today, it would probably be you.
However, before i put my vote anywhere, lets play Question Time. I'd like everyone in the game (including myself, though im gonna let a few others post answers before i do) to answer who they would A) Cop, B) Doc, and C) Vig if they had to do so right now, with reasons. The reasons are more important then the names, so make sure you dont forget em!